Perhaps it's unfair ... to hold Isbell to his own lofty standards. Compared to those of his contemporaries, these songs are still miles ahead, particularly album highlight "If We Were Vampires."
The songs — though sparely produced as usual — sound picked over, like they've been played too many times and have lost their fire.
Comfortable, but numbing. It all sounds great, but the songs don't sink in, don't push past the surface.
Finding his inspiration at the intersection of country and heavy metal, The Outsiders offers a dozen powerfully rocking tracks that sound like little else on the radio, anywhere on the dial. This is, emphatically, a good thing.
Throughout Here is What is, Lanois’ fifth, and best, record, we hear reverberations of the past, and meditations on the future.