Leilani - Precious Treasure
55

Very Spice-Girl-Britpop, but the cheeky attitude and some of the campy hooks on tracks like "I Am The Greatest" (including that sample) are enough to make this a tolerable release - just a shame that some of the other deep cuts are pretty major duds.

Davyd Nightingale - DIGITAL SILENCE
48

Received on Twitter-now-known-as today, and although the guy asking folks to give it an ear and a thought seems sweet enough, I'm going to have to be honest here and say I think more work is needed. The production is just kind of there, some of the vocal performances (particularly on Problem) are more than stretching it, and lyrically I found "Digital Silence" a bit corny.

"Nightingale" is genuinely decent on all fronts, although it does feel like it is sonically at ... read more

Kelis - Milkshake
25

Kelis disinterestedly repeats the hook often enough that you almost forget this is meant to be a song. Listen to the production properly, too: It's so unpleasant and static for most of the track. Eugh.

Curious though: Has the price of a milkshake lesson gone up with inflation?

Benefits - Constant Noise
80

An album that made me think of Mark Fisher. A very British class-politic going on here, at times beautifully put together, at times haunting. Mostly, though, I struggle to understand all the 0-9s. Did you give it a chance?

Music, to me, is about whether you enjoy it and often about whether it has something worth saying, too. This is music I enjoy in big part *because* it has something to say - a howl into a void about how unforgiveable it is that this world is so alienating, painful, ... read more

My Morning Jacket - is
68

is fine i guess. bit of an indie-dreamy nostalgia for a few decades ago thing going on here.

Brittany Broski - Adore You (Cover)
0

i'm happy to be the joyless one who calls this absolute garbage.

Men I Trust - Equus Asinus
80

Julee Cruise for the Gen Z-ers lounge bar. Very pleasant and holds your attention - either as a cafe soundtrack, as sleep music, or as an instrument to make you think about the things you have loved, lost, or regretted.

Selena Gomez - I Said I Love You First
35

I've been waiting for Ms Gomez to discover the depth many of her contemporaries did years ago - and instead, she produces this vapid, adolescent, lovesick project. One that forgoes substance for an attempt at diversified sounds to the extent that it thins out on the ground and hits my ear like hot air.

I ascribe no credit nor disappointment to Blanco, who proved himself comprehensively to be a busted flush worth no thought or attention years ago.

Selena is in her thirties, now. Not an ... read more

Alex Warren - Ordinary
20

So this is what the algorithm (and, as a result, a bunch of middling fame-hungry hacks) decided the Sound Of Today is?

Abysmal. No substance and no texture. Screw this.

Geraint Jarman A'r Cynganeddwyr - Hen Wlad Fy Nhadau
80

A Welsh language, reggae, new-wave, rock-adjacent album from the late 70s. I understand how this album isn't more widely-recognised, but *still*. Not often am I so easily able to make it through an entire album without losing my enthusiasm.

+ Steddfod Yn Y Ddinas, Ethiopia Newydd, Merch Ty Cyngor,

Madonna - Into the Groove
100

The most successful elements of her earliest singles stitched together in this almost scientifically *correct* way.

Lizzo - Still Bad
45

Way to tee yourself up for the critics.

It's not that bad, for the record, but it is bland. Flavourless juice.

Kim Fowley - Outrageous
18

It doesn't always have to be "so bad it is good". Sometimes it can be "so bad it is bad". Points only for the unintentional humour in how for-the-ladies faux-deep this so clearly is, but those can only go so far when the overarching product is legitimately a nightmare to listen to. Chinese Water Torture indeed. Fucking hell.

Frankie Grande - Rhythm of Love
15

The production sounds cheap and the vocal here is usually *dreadful*, which is an accomplishment all its own with how little this track seemed to require of him.

Say No To Nepotism!

JADE - FUFN (Fuck You For Now)
72

it isn't her most impressive single, nor is it her most artistically notable, but it soars, it howls, and it beats along. can't argue with that;

Chappell Roan - The Giver
85

breaking out the capital F FIDDLES for this one

the specific way chappell stretches and strains her voice lends itself so, so, so perfectly well to a country-tinged sound, so i'm thoroughly unsurprised that the result here is so unambiguously effective. great writing, great performing, a *fabulous* instrumental.

80

Much like Xtina's "Bionic", Gaga's ARTPOP was a flop at the time that has since been reframed as a misunderstood masterpiece. Unlike "Bionic", however, ARTPOP genuinely is a misunderstood masterpiece.

The first three tracks are some of her best work period. The title-track a magnificent space odyssey that is often left behind in the praise. Applause always an overrated single but it is still a high-power Gaga single. Swine an exceptional pang of desire and ... read more

Madonna - Madonna
77

Madge, still wet behind the ears, lacking in technical ability, and about as unpolished as she was ever going to be, kicks ass on this record. Eight tracks, and only the kind-of-middling "I Know It" really gets lost in the shuffle - but both the production and her raw unbridled power, hunger, and ambition come together frequently, particularly on the club smacker "Burning Up" and the euphoric "Holiday", to produce a level of magnetism that cemented her as one to ... read more

Sugababes - Jungle
23

Production is an audio vomit-comet and the vocals aren't smoothening anything out. Get me out of here!

1
...
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
...
18
Create an account to rate and review albums.
Recent Review Comments
On EmiliaViolet's review of Kim Petras - Freak It
"She sacrificed a lot of goodwill just to have him hold her back *this* much... crazy."
On InspectorNorse's review of Self Esteem - A Complicated Woman
"So many 100s and a 10 for The Dreaming..."
On DJ_Groggy's review of Benefits - Constant Noise
"100% on this one. I struggle to understand how anyone could come away from this experience having not only felt nothing, but failing to see how anyone could feel anything from it."
On RobiBlueX's review of Amy Winehouse - Back to Black
"Back to Black is an album I think many of us have an intense nostalgia for, but I think it would be fair to conclude that it is very single-heavy and most notable for the extent to which it singularly dominated a lane in music in the late 00s more than it is for the raw quality/table-shaking, yeah."
On UrbanPiano's review of Rebecca Black - SALVATION
"the only track on this album that sounds even remotely like it could've come from BRAT is maybe "tears in my pocket", and even the hyperpop-*influenced* stuff on here is at most 3 of the 7 tracks. not every energetic/bold pop production is a charli ripoff oh my lord."
On FKA twigs - EUSEXUA
"@DrakeBonna on balance, i do! five tracks on this are great, and it is solidly "above average"/mid, but *come on*, when we heard eusexua, drums of death, etc, we expected exhilarating, not the mixed bag this fundamentally is."
On pinkgump's review of SOPHIE - SOPHIE
"exactly my take. much of this album is clearly for the underground rave, and i get it isn't quite the overwhelming behemoth her fans were used to, but that does not make it a Bad Album."
On Charls143's review of Katy Perry - 143
"she made that album 14 years ago and now she's surviving on literal ava max rejects and 2012 buzzfeed pop be so real sister."
On younglilchild's review of Katy Perry - LIFETIMES
"It's not good!"
On Marianl's review of Katy Perry - LIFETIMES
"Chat GPT writing Katy's singles *and* her reviews now."
On thme's review of Katy Perry - LIFETIMES
"1000%. People are *right* that this is better than Woman's World... the problem, though, is it's still YouTube tutorial soundtracking at *best*."
On Eminem - The Death of Slim Shady (Coup de GrĂ¢ce)
"@thepinfall My point is that nobody cares about Caitlyn Jenner at this particular point in time, and if the conceptual aim is to create controversy, well: It is the kind of line that would have created controversy a decade ago. At this point, you might've noticed that it landed with a dull thud for most people."
Advertisement

April Playlist