It's a little up and down. Lyrically, Fay seems interested in being Bob Dylan. But then it's paired with Ray Russell's blue guitar. So at times it's really striking and memorable and easy to see how it influenced punk and folk singers that followed.
I like when people who weren't alive in 1989 come in and review an album with "oh, this is underwhelming." Like, cool...go enjoy your Magdalena Bay album or whatever. You can't possibly add context or understand the impact this album had on indie rock when you've spent your whole life consuming the watered down version. You think I'm dead, but I'll just sail away.
A ridiculously solid album that combines a few genres and probably lands somewhere between power pop and pop punk, but with a 90s indie rock influence and even a hint of alt country. Reminiscent of the early albums by Katie Crutchfield, both as Waxahachie or in PS Eliot.