Various Artists

The Metallica Blacklist

Critic Score
Based on 8 reviews
User Score
Based on 102 ratings
September 10, 2021 / Release Date
Compilation / Format
Blackened / Label
Heavy Metal / Genre
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
Metal Injection

For fans who don’t have the time to sit through all six hours of The Blacklist, some tracks are worth checking out more than others.

80
Metal Hammer

Ultimately, this is a towering show of force that underscores how, unlike any other band in history, Metallica have transcended heavy metal and emerged as one of music’s greatest cultural exports. And while nobody’s going to love all the versions on The Metallica Blacklist, there’s a track for every person, mood and playlist. It’s one hell of a fun ride.

70
The Line of Best Fit

Even with the highest highs of this collection … it still feels like a corporate pat on the back.

70
Clash
Bar a couple of underwhelming or wholly unoriginal takes, 'The Metallica Blacklist' is a surprisingly solid listen considering its breadth.
60
Pitchfork

The Black Album launched Metallica to superstardom because of its approachability, but in its attempts to offer something for everyone, Blacklist spreads itself too thin.

60
AllMusic

The Metallica Blacklist is fantastic for cherry-picking tracks from your favorite artists or listening in on the more outlandish interpretations of metal classics, but taken as a whole, it's daunting to the point of making even the highlights difficult to appreciate.

60
NME
Once it’s all over, with the help of a decent online support group, or a saint’s patience, you can pick out a fantastic tribute to one of metal’s sacred texts. Maybe even two.
40
Mojo

The Blacklist ... runs to a self-aggrandising 53 tracks. A handful work, either by overhauling the source material ... or because the artists sound at ease with their chosen tunes.

Styg
30

Yes, I listened to the entire thing. It was fine. There were some great tracks, some terrible ones, some hilarious ones, but it was just waaay too long for a project that is mostly 7/10 songs. It's fun hearing some 2010s bro-country guy cover Wherever I May Roam, it's fun hearing some east coast hip hop group cover The Unforgiven, but I don't really wanna hear 10 different renditions of the same song in a row. Fucking hell why did I even do this

Musicnerdd
65

A great idea, that's executed better than everyone expected

For the 30th anniversary of the release of their best selling album "the black album" metallica decided to get some crirically acclaimed artists such as weezer, ghost, rina sawayama, st. Vincent and etc to cover some of the songs from this popular and well praised album. While most of the artists here can't even be categorized under the same genre as metallica, they actually manage to deliver a great, different and ... read more

sockholderz
NR

why is it so fucking long

More popular reviews
NR

ain't no way weezer and Mac Demarco covered enter sandman

TED_UNIRATER
40

Was kinda dookie

BestiPlayer999
70

What is this?
Some good covers and that's basically it.
J Balvin what are you doing here😭

More recent reviews
Purchasing The Metallica Blacklist from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

Disc 1
1Alessia Cara, The Warning - Enter Sandman
4:23
78
2Mac DeMarco - Enter Sandman
5:46
82
3Ghost - Enter Sandman
3:51
86
4Juanes - Enter Sandman
4:53
5Rina Sawayama - Enter Sandman
5:33
74
6Weezer - Enter Sandman
5:34
49
7Sam Fender - Sad But True (Live)
3:50
8Jason Isbell - Sad But True
4:30
78
9Mexican Institute of Sound - Sad But True
4:31
10Royal Blood - Sad But True
5:28
80
11St. Vincent - Sad But True
4:12
67
12White Reaper - Sad But True
5:22
13YB - Sad But True
4:03
Disc 2
1Biffy Clyro - Holier Than Thou
5:09
2The Chats - Holier Than Thou
2:25
75
3OFF! - Holier Than Thou
3:03
4PUP - Holier Than Thou
3:55
79
5Corey Taylor - Holier Than Thou
4:10
6Cage the Elephant - The Unforgiven
5:53
46
7Vishal Dadlani, DIVINE, Shor Police - The Unforgiven
4:20
feat. Metallica
8Diet Cig - The Unforgiven
4:47
9Flatbush Zombies - The Unforgiven
4:36
10Ha-Ash - The Unforgiven
4:05
11José Madero - The Unforgiven
4:00
12Moses Sumney - The Unforgiven
5:33
Disc 3
1J Balvin - Wherever I May Roam
2:38
feat. Metallica
10
2Chase & Status - Wherever I May Roam
3:06
3The Neptunes - Wherever I May Roam
3:56
feat. Metallica
70
4Jon Pardi - Wherever I May Roam
6:44
5SebastiAn - Don't Tread On Else Matters
5:54
feat. Metallica
6Portugal. The Man - Don't Tread On Me
4:14
7Volbeat - Don't Tread On Me
3:38
8The HU - Through the Never
4:06
85
9Tomi Owó - Through the Never
3:06
10Phoebe Bridgers - Nothing Else Matters
4:34
89
11Miley Cyrus - Nothing Else Matters
6:35
79
12Dave Gahan - Nothing Else Matters
5:09
81
13Mickey Guyton - Nothing Else Matters
4:30
14Dermot Kennedy - Nothing Else Matters
3:01
15Mon Laferte - Nothing Else Matters
5:56
Disc 4
1Igor Levit - Nothing Else Matters
5:12
2My Morning Jacket - Nothing Else Matters
3:26
3PG Roxette - Nothing Else Matters
3:48
4Darius Rucker - Nothing Else Matters
6:52
5Chris Stapleton - Nothing Else Matters
8:14
6TRESOR - Nothing Else Matters
6:24
7Goodnight, Texas - Of Wolf and Man
3:23
8IDLES - The God That Failed
3:56
78
9Imelda May - The God That Failed
4:04
10Cherry Glazerr - My Friend of Misery
3:30
11Izïa - My Friend of Misery
4:24
12Kamasi Washington - My Friend of Misery
6:47
85
13Rodrigo y Gabriela - My Friend of Misery
4:09
Total Length: 4 hours, 5 minutes
Comments (5)
Sign in to comment
3w
3mo
5mo
6mo
9mo

April Playlist