Stardust

Critic Score
Based on 2 reviews
1963 Ratings: #38 / 50
User Score
Based on 104 ratings
1963 Ratings: #93
November 1963 / Release Date
LP / Format
Prestige / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

spencermusicman
91

criminally underrated. coltrane's work on this website is never rated as high as it should be.

Tee8
60

JONATHAN WILLIAM COLTRANE DEEP DIVE #38

Yeah, Danny Brown did it better.

This album has an oddly large amount of plays on Spotify, especially the first two tracks.
Not sure what is so special about Time After Time that got it 31 million streams, but good for Trane I guess.

This album's kind of a nothing burger.
It's very stereotypical, comfortable, easy-going jazz.
I imagine Prestige is very much to blame for Coltrane's continuous pushing of this rather bland style, since ... read more

SilverStar555
69

JOHN COLTRANE DEEP DIVE #19

A relaxing, albeit somewhat redundant record.

These are some more mellow RVG cuts, and I like it. Really screams late 50s jazz (because it is), has a nice slow mood to it, really easy record to relax to and smoke a cigar or something. Break out the scotch for this one.

Stardust is the best track here, but every other track sounds so similar to it that there isn't much variation. It's mildly melancholic but mostly just soothing, which is kinda ... read more

More popular reviews
Tee8
60

JONATHAN WILLIAM COLTRANE DEEP DIVE #38

Yeah, Danny Brown did it better.

This album has an oddly large amount of plays on Spotify, especially the first two tracks.
Not sure what is so special about Time After Time that got it 31 million streams, but good for Trane I guess.

This album's kind of a nothing burger.
It's very stereotypical, comfortable, easy-going jazz.
I imagine Prestige is very much to blame for Coltrane's continuous pushing of this rather bland style, since ... read more

Gaccuardi
81

Really Solid Album. The only song I wasn't crazy about is Time After Time, that's not because I don't like it I just think It's not all that memorable, and kinda like the most stereotypical jazz song ever. The other songs: Stardust, Love Thy Neighbor, and Then I'll be tired of you are all wonderful. They really remind me of Mill Valley at night (which is a town 30 minutes north of San Fransisco).

SilverStar555
69

JOHN COLTRANE DEEP DIVE #19

A relaxing, albeit somewhat redundant record.

These are some more mellow RVG cuts, and I like it. Really screams late 50s jazz (because it is), has a nice slow mood to it, really easy record to relax to and smoke a cigar or something. Break out the scotch for this one.

Stardust is the best track here, but every other track sounds so similar to it that there isn't much variation. It's mildly melancholic but mostly just soothing, which is kinda ... read more

More recent reviews
Purchasing Stardust from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Stardust
10:41
77
2Time After Time
7:45
77
3Love Thy Neighbor
9:22
72
4Then I'll Be Tired of You
9:27
72
Total Length: 37 minutes
Comments
Sign in to comment
No one has said anything yet.

June Playlist