Definitely overhated, but also far from perfect. There's nothing offensively bad on this album, just some songs that end up being kind of boring despite trying to convey some serious intensity. Your Possible Pasts is very uninteresting, but is saved by a good guitar solo. The Gunner's Dream is gorgeous and perfect and the last three tracks are fantastic. The fact that there's just an impromptu ear-shattering explosion halfway through has always been funny to me.
The Post War Dream - 87
Your Possible Pasts - 87
One of the Few - 73
When the Tigers Broke Free - 97
The Hero's Return - 85
The Gunner's Dream - 100
Paranoid Eyes - 86
Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert - 65
The Fletcher Memorial Home - 98
Southampton Dock - 80
The Final Cut - 100
Not Now John - 99
Two Suns in the Sunset - 100
= 89 average
Miscellaneous: +0
Total: 89