I know this is kinda the general fav melanie album but it's the one i dislike the most. The sound of this album feels very disconnected and the story doesn't really flow well without the accompanying movie. Fav song: Teacher's Pet

This album was so important to me in middle school ijbol. I really hate the infantilization trope in this album it's so uncomfortable. Fav song: Soap

This album is so amazing I could def see it becoming my next 100 after a few more listens. I love the rage and religious symbols in this album. Fav song: Man Is Like a Spring Flower

This album is a really beautiful work of art. I love the recurring whale theme through this project and the string arrangements. Fav song: Dark Angel

This was actually a really amazing album. I wish she kept making music like this. This album really showed growth following the previous album with more complex sounds and unique songs. Fav song: Kill V. Maim

Honestly the deluxe edition tracks were overall better than the standard edition tracks. They showed a greater range of what she can do and had more interesting sounds. Fav song: Nothing!

I liked the concept of this album but i didn't love the execution. I felt like there wasn't a great cohesiveness to this album. Fav song: The Great Impersonator

This album is also really amazing. There hasn't been a single big thief project that hasn't been amazing so far. Like all their albums, the lyrics and emotion of the music is really what stands out. Fav song: Not

I loved this album it is so good. The lyrics on this albums are so good and really emotional. Fav song: Cattails

I really liked this album. It's such a good indie rock/folk album with such strong emotions throughout. Fav song: Mary

This is a really good rock album. I like their sound it's pretty unique but also influential of other things that came out after this album. Fav song: 12:51

This was certainly an album. I felt like it kinda lacked any substance to it and it would get weirdly religious every so often. Most listenable song: Balboa Park

I like this album. It's a classic 2000s indie rock album and feels very formative of the time. Fav song: Last Nite

I really liked this album. I enjoy this tyle of indie rock with pop influences. The sound on the album was pretty similar but I liked it so that was a positive ijbol. Fav song: Head Down

I like this album. It's a really nice electronic/pop album with a really cohesive ethereal feel. Fav song: Genesis

I really enjoyed this album. I love the soundscape on this album and the whole thing is amazing to listen to. Fav song: Movies for Guys

I really like this EP. I love Jane's more rock stuff and this is just a really good little collection of some of those songs. Fav song: Vulture City

I really enjoyed this album as well. I like that they are able to sorta stay within the indie pop sphere but add a different flavour on the 3 albums of theirs i've listened to. The more rock influences on this album work really well. Fav song: Money

I enjoyed this album. It's a fun more dancey indie pop record that works out really well. Fav song: Nothing's Impossible

I liked some parts of this album. I enjoyed the dream pop moments more than some of the shoegazey moments. Fav song: Forget Me