Def an improvement over their last album IMO, which I already was a decent fan of. After a while this starts to go in one ear and out the other a teeny bit, but overall it's still a very enjoyable listen. I wouldn't say a single track here is below at least decent quality.👍
Love Jukebox the ghost, but idk about this one. There is some good stuff that gets bogged down by the mediocre stuff -- and there is a lot of that considering it's an hour-long album. It seems like for a lot of the songs, they wrote just a single phrase for them and repeat that line over and over its not bad overall though and is decent at worst.
Not as good as Hollow Knight's IMO, but, let's be real. This is still so peak 😭🙏
Might be the best Panic! Album idk, still can't really say I'm a fan. Nearly Witches is goated though idc. Some highlights and somew low points but ig it's not too bad.
Definitely their best album yet. Excited to see where they go from here!
Maybe I didn't rate it high enough lol
Create an account to rate and review albums.
Recent Review Comments
On Machinery Of The Human Heart - Surgery
"Definitely a grower. Love this!"
On firegold763's review of Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
"It's lowkey overrated, but it's not that bad 😭"
On Florence + the Machine - Everybody Scream
"I like Witch Dance too."
On Jukebox the Ghost - Phantasmagorical Vol. 1
"Genuinely if this album was cut down to Phantasmagorical, End of the Show, Sea Change, In the Waves, Flash!, Emotional Fraud, Wild Ride, Olivia, Save a Little Room, If You Were A Color, and maybe like Stranger or Truth or smth, it would be a really good album. But it's so long with a lot of mediocre or just kinda alright filler that idk I don't think I can rate it higher sadly. Maybe I'll give it a slight bump."
On Jukebox the Ghost - Cheers
"what was I yapping about here holy"
On VinylFantasy's review of Dirt Poor Robins - The Raven Locks Act 1
"I do like Steam Powered Giraffe, so I LOVE this artist. Although the 3rd act is definitely the best. Did you get to Maximilian Van Spee in act 2 though? (You probably wouldn't remember....) That is my favorite act 2 track"
On AUD1OR1OT's review of The Cardigans - Gran Turismo
"UGHH if more of the songs on here were like Do You Believe with that kind of sound I would have rated the album higher"
On Swagmandan21's review of The Brobecks - Violent Things
"I don't think Dallon Weekes (the brobecks) even listens to MCR lol"
On charcoal's review of Panic! at the Disco - Viva Las Vengeance
"You could say that you didn't have "high high hopes?""
Advertisement