Let's make a list. Justification not required. If I don't like something, I probably won't rate it.
Rough list breakdown:
93+ = MY GOAT (has to have been out for enough time)
80-92 = They're REALLY Good
70-80 = They're pretty good
55-70 = It's Alright
<55 = Not for Me
Doesn't quite crack my GOATs list, but they are very good listening and/or have a certain something that bumps it past the "good" list. (up to ~92/100)