Arcade Fire

Critic Score
Based on 6 reviews
User Score
Based on 341 ratings
2003 Ratings: #490
June 15, 2003 / Release Date
EP / Format
No Label, Merge / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
The Irish Times
Arcade Fire sound a lot more ethereal than on anything else they've done; if you can put aside your quibbles with the production, there's some fantastic stuff here.
70
AllMusic
While each of the seven tracks contained herein are fully realized, they are as unfocused as they are beautiful, resulting in an intangible, dreamlike atmosphere that reduces each cut -- no matter how deep -- down to a mere scratch.
70
Sputnikmusic
As a stand-alone EP this is the kind of thing that would make you very interested in the band, as it's clear that they've got something special going, which when they get right, really bursts into your mind.
68
Pitchfork

The EP shows a band still finding its strengths and developing its sound, unsure of its talent for cathartic drama ... The band generates tension and energy, but don't always recognize the best way to unravel it.

60
Uncut
JackTony
70

Pretty nice actually. You can tell they are just about ready to truly explore their sound.

quinnishere
90

An amazingly thoughtful and heartfelt release that is honestly, for me, a close second place in their discography.

Lyrics: heart-tugging, emotive, and evocative. Much of what makes Funeral (soon to come) so brilliant is its usage of imagery ("then I'll dig a tunnel / from my window to yours"). I would argue that this EP is the second most well-written AF release. Lines like "The headlights look like diamonds / The taillights burn like coals / Tell me how this story ends / Before ... read more

edgyrras
79

rough around the edges debut that showcases some of their best atributes and some meandering as well. This is probably the closest you can get to another funeral, it has the same vibes and the instrumentals resemble the ones on their debut LP with the constant melodies and switchs, the writing def got improved but this is no doubt an incredible EP

More popular reviews
Kirbesei
86

Hol up, this is fun as hell!

Noah_savage5
65

A sadly unimaginative release from one of the most interesting, respected bands of the time, it serves a purpose though and is a necessary listen to a fan, especially before hearing their debut album 'Funeral'.

butterfly_wings
78

one amazing song, a couple good songs and some mediocre/bad songs.

More recent reviews
Purchasing Arcade Fire from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

June Playlist