Critic Score
Based on 7 reviews
2023 Ratings: #719 / 787
User Score
Based on 103 ratings
June 9, 2023 / Release Date
LP / Format
Ninja Tune / Label
Jayda G, Jack PeñateProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

74
Pitchfork
The Canadian producer and DJ’s second album pays tribute to her father’s memory, fusing home-video recordings with ambrosial disco, soul, and dance-pop.
70
musicOMH
Disco-house grooves combine with a mainstream sensibility on an album dedicated to her father.
70
PopMatters

Jayda G’s Guy is an admirable and occasionally affecting project that balances both personal vulnerabilities with uplifting and life-affirming music.

70
AllMusic
Jayda does a magnificent job connecting deeply personal stories with accessible music.
70
Exclaim!
The record is an achievement of pop-house production, and Jayda's performance throughout is earnest and enthralling — It's a strong effort and vital evolution in her ever-shifting career.
70
The Sydney Morning Herald
A sprinkling of sombre and slower moments would’ve made for a richer, more interesting album, but it remains a poignant, heartfelt tribute as well as a possible play for increased crossover appeal
50
Loud and Quiet
It’s a personal offering, and although that’s absolutely valid, perhaps it is one that will resonate more with its creator than with a general audience
hbear
74

The production is absolutely fabulous but the vocals leave something to be desired at times. I think there are some songs that are quite beautiful in spite of the vocals though (sometimes they even add to it as well)

AngelHerntz
68

Íntimo y personal synth-pop and house. Aunque no me convenció del todo reconozco lo emotivo del trabajo de la productora y DJ canadiense, Jayda G. Aprecio su concepto, su diatriba familiar incrustada literalmente entre track y track, donde podemos escuchar las profundas e importantes palabras de su ya fallecido padre. No siempre he estado de acuerdo con dicho concepto, el de introducir skits no musicalizados, un océano de ejemplos de ello tenemos en la industria el rap; mas ... read more

deluxeversion
50

zzzzzz that was so boring im sorry dear

More popular reviews
commithash
62

Outstandingly un-special on first listen. I can see why this would be rated low as it's just not anything special. However, overtime it grew on me a lot and some of the tracks (Blue Lights, Scars, and Sapphires of Gold) truly entranced me. This album probably started as a "eh, not really" to an "okay" off determination alone. I have a lot of faith in her future releases, especially after The Shiver.

fkagustavo
10

This was shockingly bad...

hausenger
20

questionable, ★½

More recent reviews
Purchasing Guy from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist