Critic Score
Based on 21 reviews
2013 Ratings: #1078 / 1141
User Score
Based on 126 ratings
2013 Ratings: #822
June 10, 2013 / Release Date
LP / Format
Columbia / Label
Dave Sitek, Beady EyeProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
AllMusic

Perhaps they're happily stuck in the past, but there's no denying that when they have a hook or melody -- and when they have a savvy producer like Sitek supporting them -- they deliver the retro goods.

70
NME

‘BE’ is certainly an improvement on ‘Different Gear...’, but it’s more of a tentative step in the right direction than a great leap forward.

60
DIY

The vocals, the terrible rhymes... it's business as usual then for Liam; it's just scrubbed up a bit.

60
The Fly

This follow-up has its share of the usual “spread your wings and learn to FLAIIIIEE” hokum, but also moments – the lazily imperious ‘Flick Of The Finger’ and ‘Iz Rite’ among them – that remind us how we’d miss him if he went.

60
musicOMH

Although the musical advance Beady Eye have made in BE does not extend to the clumsy lyrics, Liam shows he is not just a balls-out bawler and the band sound sharp. It looks like they might be around for a while yet.

58
Pitchfork

BE is somewhat more adventurous than Different Gear, and certainly more dynamic.

48
Paste

Losing the man responsible for the songs that made anyone care about Oasis spelled disaster, and after skimming by on their debut, Be sounds exactly like a band that has lost its songwriter.

40
PopMatters

BE is too often clunky n’ hollow and surprisingly downbeat n’ dog-tired.

30
Sputnikmusic

The two biggest problems with BE are thus; the energy that made their first LP a surprisingly decent effort has been removed completely, and Liam’s lyrics have plumbed to new, previously unassailable depths of self-parody.

0
Drowned in Sound

At its best the same bland and uninspired shite that Liam has spent his career peddling, at its worst genuinely unpleasant.

DefinitelyFade
82

Sorry for being dead for like a week and a half I just lost motivation to listen to albums but I'm gonna lock the fuck in now.

The second and final Beady Eye album is honestly, underrated. A bunch of bangers and only around one weak track, and then they end it off with a 10/10 song. If Beady Eye didn't form instantly after Oasis split, I think they would've done better, and if this was 2017 Liam's voice, holy shit... I only heard this once in 2024 so coming back for a ... read more

LiamFalconer
67

only good thing about this album besides the first three songs, is that it has tits on the cover art.

StrawberryFloyd
NR

Oh boy! Yonkers on an Oasis album cover! What I've always wanted!

More popular reviews
sandwichmuncher
70

a step in the right direction from dgss would have really wanted to see a third beady eye

LiamFalconer
67

only good thing about this album besides the first three songs, is that it has tits on the cover art.

StrawberryFloyd
NR

Oh boy! Yonkers on an Oasis album cover! What I've always wanted!

More recent reviews
Purchasing BE from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist