Best Song - VCR / Wholeheartedly / Of Blue / For Keeps
Worst Song - What We On / On McAfee
Overrated - WRK
Underrated - Wholeheartedly

Best Song - Crabs In A Bucket / Yeah Right
Worst Song - Alyssa Interlude
Overrated - Big Fish
Underrated - N/A

Best Song - We Used To Vacation / God, Make Up Your Mind
Worst Song - Too monotonous to have a standout worst
Overrated - Hang Me Up To Dry
Underrated - Hospital Beds

Best Song - Black Marmalade / Cotton
Worst Song - TV Guide
Overrated - The Big Bad Wolf
Underrated - N/A

Best Song - Bread Song / Haldern
Worst Song - Mark's Theme
Overrated - Chaos Space Marine
Underrated - Intro

Best Song - I Will Follow You Into The Dark / Brothers On A Hotel Bed
Worst Song - N/A
Overrated - N/A
Underrated - Different Names For The Same Thing / Stable Song

Best Song - undressed
Worst Song - They're too monotonous to have a standout worst
Overrated - back to friends
Underrated - canal street

Best Song - M79 / The Kids Don't Stand A Chance
Worst Song - Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa / Bryn / One (Blake's Got A New Face)
Overrated - N/A
Underrated - I Stand Corrected

Like AJR and TØP had a baby except it was good

Best Song - ok ok? / still feel. / TrusT
Worst Song - Pure Gold
Overrated - arrow
Underrated - Maybe / creature

Best Song - Cigarettes In The Theatre
Worst Song - Do You Want It All?
Overrated - What You Know
Underrated - You're Not Stubborn

Best Song - Of Moons, Birds, & Monsters
Worst Song - Pieces Of What
Overrated - N/A
Underrated - The Handshake / Future Reflections

Best Song - Sugar Talking / Don't Worry I'll Make You Worry / Goodbye
Worst Song - Go Go Juice
Overrated - N/A
Underrated - Sugar Talking

Best Song - Siberian Breaks / Brian Eno / Congratulations
Worst Song - Flash Delirium
Overrated - Flash Delirium
Underrated - Lady Dada's Nightmare

Best Song - My Generation (the cover being the best is bad)
Worst Song - All of them
Overrated - It's four songs man
Underrated - It's four songs man

Best Song - Android / No One Knows
Worst Song - Dominated Love Slave
Overrated - 80
Underrated - Android

Last four songs on streaming version of Kerplunk are bonuses from another project, reviewed on Sweet Children EP

Best Song - Breaking The Girl / Suck My Kiss / Righteous & The Wicked
Worst Song - They're Red Hot
Overrated - Give It Away
Underrated - Righteous & The Wicked

This album is what I imagine a nightmare would sound like (in a good way)

Best Song - I Might Be Wrong / Knives Out / Life In A Glass House
Worst Song - Hunting Bears
Overrated - N/A
Underrated - Life In A Glass House

Best Song - Parallel World / Emit Remmus / Savior
Worst Song - I Like Dirt / Purple Stain
Overrated - Scar Tissue
Underrated - Right On Time

Best Song - Death Grips Is Online / Disappointed
Worst Song - Little Richard
Overrated - N/A
Underrated - N/A

Best Song - Outside Tweaking
Worst Song - Pick one and it's a good contender
Overrated - Goose and the Juice
Underrated - Pick none and it's a good contender