AFI (The Blood Album)

Critic Score
Based on 16 reviews
2017 Ratings: #668 / 966
User Score
Based on 153 ratings
2017 Ratings: #729
January 20, 2017 / Release Date
LP / Format
Concord / Label
Jade Puget, Matt HydeProducer
Davey HavokWriter
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
Kerrang!
You better get ready to start your "Best Albums of 2017" list--a serious contender has arrived.
83
A.V. Club
The record illustrates that the members of AFI are deeply committed to forward motion, and remain as fired up now as they were 25 years ago.
80
AllMusic
There's certainly enough here to prove that post-Nitro AFI are a better and stronger group, unafraid to continue pushing their sound with each release.
80
Alternative Press

Epic-sounding and true to that signature AFI sound, AFI (The Blood Album) will be a record that stands out for hardcore fans, while picking up some new ones along the way. The fire is definitely still inside AFI.

80
Q Magazine
It still occupies dark territory but this time excellent songs like Hidden Knives are defined by urgency, as well as venom.
75
The 405

While AFI (The Blood Album) may not have the mainstream crossover potential that the band enjoyed a decade ago with Sing the Sorrow and DECEMBERUNDERGROUND, it is still a highly enjoyable album that both diehard fans and anyone looking for massive rock hooks alike should enjoy, despite faltering a bit toward the end.

70
Drowned in Sound

AFI has little in the way of stumbles and no real clunkers to speak of, but a sense of familiarity and repetition creep in before the finish. It’s not enough to tarnish the gems but a greater commitment to ruthlessness would have been welcome. Still, this is a strong rebirth from an outfit that, perhaps appropriately, doesn’t quite know how to wither away.

70
Clash
Fortunately, it’s pretty much business as usual on ‘The Blood Album’.
70
Classic Rock

The punk energy remains, frontman Davy Havok’s vocal delivery dripping with drama and passion, but with a glorious, gilded production job from guitarist Jade Puget, AFI (The Blood Album) luxuriates in a velvety richness that makes it a sumptuous listen.

60
Exclaim!

The Blood Album ... It's hard to shake off singer Davey Havok's sterile lyrics, especially when many of the choruses lean heavily on his bold, operatic delivery yet are somewhat squandered on half-cocked one-liners. For a 14-track record, there are some questionable inclusions, too.

58
Consequence of Sound

In the three years since their last release, Burials, AFI had to choose between staying the course of recent history or reverting to their hardcore roots. In this case, they chose the shelter of mainstream acceptance, a predictable – if disappointing – decision.

50
Pitchfork

Perhaps it’s all worth it if The Blood Album spurs a rejuvenated interest in Sing the Sorrow and Black Sails on the Sunset, but the triumphant return of AFI is still ready when they are.

40
Sputnikmusic
AFI combine elements from their last four albums and churn out a lifeless, personalityless record that is worse than the albums it apes.
Torretti
52

Chegando próximo ao fim da discografia completa da banda AFI, me deparo com a situação inusitada que é o seu projeto de 2017 “The Blood Album”. Um projeto que é provavelmente o mais ouvido pelo meu irmão Felipe (a inspiração para ter feito esta discografia para começo de conversa). Mas que para mim, junto com o projeto ‘’Bodies’’ de 2021 são os piores trabalhos da banda, piores até ... read more

FritoRio
60

Extremely okay

MAN
21

AFI are not that great anymore, unfortunately.

More popular reviews
FaceBrookeDtCom
66

A much more softer album from AFI, compared to their earlier work. And the result is a rather inconsistent album. Some songs are great (Snow Cats and Still a Stranger), but a good chunk of the others are only Fine to Good, such as Hidden Knives, a song that sounds fine, but on a closer listen, just doesn’t hit as hard as it should. This album could’ve been made by any other band and it would still sound the same.

AP2007
70

It's alright I guess? Definitely not a 58/100, but this is definitely their weakest album since Shut Your Mouth in 1997. There weren't any bad songs per se, but this album just mostly felt bland. They had long already exercised this sound to death by the time the 2010s rolled around.

This isn't a bad album at all, but not a great album, and most certainly not an album that I'd come back to.

Torretti
52

Chegando próximo ao fim da discografia completa da banda AFI, me deparo com a situação inusitada que é o seu projeto de 2017 “The Blood Album”. Um projeto que é provavelmente o mais ouvido pelo meu irmão Felipe (a inspiração para ter feito esta discografia para começo de conversa). Mas que para mim, junto com o projeto ‘’Bodies’’ de 2021 são os piores trabalhos da banda, piores até ... read more

More recent reviews
Purchasing AFI (The Blood Album) from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist