Critic Score
Based on 18 reviews
2006 Ratings: #23 / 766
User Score
Based on 59 ratings
2006 Ratings: #352
May 29, 2006 / Release Date
LP / Format
!K7 / Label
HerbertProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
musicOMH
Inspiring and ingenious, this is an album you shouldn't be without.
100
NOW Magazine
Think of it as avant-garde composer John Cage trying his hand at disco and getting it right.
90
AllMusic
Though Herbert has outdone himself and matches his ambitions with his achievements, the songs are unmistakably his and Siciliano's, sounding like no one else, twisting and swinging and drifting with optimum vibrancy.
90
Under the Radar

It's too early to call Scale a classic, but ... Herbert has achieved one of the deftest balances of pop music and politics heard in some time.

90
Prefix

A lean, focused record, Scale is Herbert's best record to date, and a must-buy for any dance-music fan.

88
Pitchfork
Herbert has outdone himself when it comes to his usual conceptual three-ring circus. But, crucially, this time he's put all that theoretical effort into his most memorable songs.
87
Coke Machine Glow

Inch by inch -- concept, production, groove -- Scale will measure your desires and dole out exactly what you want: depth, politics, creativity, or club-ready curios.

83
A.V. Club

Some of his recent work has prioritized conceptual aims at the expense of his formidable musical talent, but Scale strikes a balance with songs as melodic and inviting as any he's ever composed.

83
Entertainment Weekly

Herbert sneakily subverts Scale's apocalyptic thematic thread into something warm and danceable.

80
PopMatters

Their politicism is woven so masterfully into the lush electronic pop medium that you’re never coerced into consideration of any one issue.

80
The Guardian
Vacuous celebrity, the nefarious American empire and the "holy mess" of the world are among the subjects channelled through the silken voice of Dani Siciliano.
80
Q Magazine

A pleasure, featuring some of his most winging music since Murphy's Ruby Blue.

60
Tiny Mix Tapes

If Dani appeared on a few less tracks here, Scale may have been one of the year's finest.

60
Uncut
Entertainingly eccentric pop, even if at times it seems to pull in too many directions.
RobiBlueForever
75

Once again, we have an album that packs a punch with plenty of vibes and nostalgic rhythms that are everywhere and sound great. Other than that, there's nothing groundbreaking here, but the songs intros were interesting yeah.

Krolljr
75

Thanks @UltimateLifeFrm for the rec! and apologies for it taking me like a billion years to finally listen to this one.
Overall, Scale is honestly doesn't really go for a very experimental sound, however, I can't say I've really heard anything that sounds like this. The album is filled with these orchestral yet funky and very rhythmically driven soul/pop tracks. Maybe it's the orchestral elements, but this album really feels like it's the soundtrack to some sort of ... read more

Joansitz
92

Amazing

More popular reviews
Purchasing Scale from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist