Favorite tracks: Hold My Liquor, Guilt Trip, On Sight
Least-favorite track: Send It Up
Average score: 74
Favorite track: Codex
Least-favorite track: Morning Mr. Magpie
Average score: 73
Favorite track: Still Beating
Least-favorite track: A Wolf Who Wears Sheeps Clothes
Favorite track: Pagan Poetry
Least-favorite track: It's Not Up to You
Average score: 95
Favorite track: Body Paint
Least-favorite track: Sculptures of Anything Goes
Favorite track: A Certain Romance
Least-favorite track: Dancing Shoes
Average score: 89
Favorite tracks: Teddy Picker, This House Is a Circus, Brianstorm
Least-favorite track: The Bad Thing
Average score: 87
Favorite tracks: Fireside, No. 1 Party Anthem, I Wanna Be Yours
Least-favorite track: Mad Sounds
Average score: 85
The biggest thing holding this album back is the fact that there really isn't anything significant to take away from the listening experience, save for a handful of outstanding tracks. Of course, the objective numbers disagree, as is to be expected from an album as commercially successful as AM.
Favorite tracks: Chamber of Reflection, Brother, Let Her Go
Least-favorite track: Goodbye Weekend
Average score: 90
The replay value on this album is insane.
Favorite tracks: There, There, Sail to the Moon, Go to Sleep
Least-favorite track: A Punchup at a Wedding
Average score: 84
There, There is one of the greatest songs ever written.
Favorite tracks: Don't Tap That Glass / Tweakin', Big Poe, Stop Playing With Me
Least-favorite track: Sugar On My Tongue
Average score: 84
I dare you to sit still for the entire runtime.
Favorite track: Alberto Balsalm
Least-favorite track: Icct Hedral (Edit)
Favorite tracks: 4, Logan Rock Witch, Yellow Calx
Least-favorite track: Goon Gumpas
Favorite tracks: SWEET / I THOUGHT YOU WANTED TO DANCE, WILSHIRE, WUSYANAME
Least-favorite track: RUNITUP
Favorite tracks: A BOY IS A GUN*, NEW MAGIC WAND, I DON'T LOVE YOU ANYMORE
Least-favorite track: EARFQUAKE
Average score: 97
If I hear one person call I DON'T LOVE YOU ANYMORE a skip, I'm getting a new magic wand.
Favorite tracks: The Sound, Helpless Child, Blood Section
Least-favorite track: Hypogirl
Average score: 89
Helpless Child is the greatest song ever written.