This hits all the marks in my book. Lush indie folk with some real emotional power behind it.
John, please don't say that word. The rest of the album is good, though.
Smiley Smile takes the conceptually-justified eccentricities of the planned Smile and deprives them of their connective tissue, rendering the entire thing nonsensical. Instead of thematically consistent weirdness, it just comes across as weird for the sake of weird.