masterpiece.

neat

I wasn't expecting this album to be very good. Needless to say, I came out of it pleasantly surprised. It wasn't the best thing they've ever done, but it still manages to sound and feel unique and fresh.

This is basically the best RTJ album.

ayup

Damn, this was nice. Wasn't expecting this to sound nearly as good as it did.

Pretty neat. Hardwired and Am I Savage stand out as two favorites of mine from this album.

Actually pretty underrated.

Okay this album isn't as bad as some people make it out, but it's still far from perfect. Same goes for Reload.

This is the most annoying Metallica album because of the way people talk about it. Either you think it’s one of their best albums, or you hate it and the people that like it because “GURGH, POSER”. Fuck off, 8/10.

Definitely the most divisive of Metallica’s first four albums. I’d say I really love it, but it’s sorta the weakest of their first four.

What a fucking album.

13 years, and I'd say it was worth it. It's no 10,000 Days, but still a very competent metal album that stands up to Tool's earlier work.

Best Metallica album.

Best Weezer album in years. Wasn't expecting it to be nearly this good.

hell yeah.

A great starting point for a band like Metallica. A strong start that still leaves room for more.

A pretty good metalcore album. You can tell it's the album I Prevail wanted to make.

Definitely a shining example of Phil Elverum's earlier work.

Jesus fucking Christ.....