Critic Score
Based on 12 reviews
2019 Ratings: #439 / 817
User Score
Based on 267 ratings
2019 Ratings: #406
January 11, 2019 / Release Date
LP / Format
Thomas BartlettProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
Under the Radar

This is a remarkable, quietly powerful, and astoundingly beautiful album from an artist who now deserves to take his place among his influences.

80
Sputnikmusic

What we end up with here is Angelo De Augustine’s most brazen step forward to date. Tomb sees him not buried, but bursting forth with flourishing atmospheres. By nature his music is still very soft-spoken – almost Elliott Smith-like in that regard – but this is no longer the crackly, static-bound lo-fi songwriter that gave us Spirals of Silence and Swim Inside The Moon.

80
The Line of Best Fit

Tomb is a record of heartbreak that never wallows, a reflection on loss that does not allow itself to become stuck in the past, and resolutely optimistic at its core. What we find here, on what is arguably the pinnacle of his output to date, is De Augustine achieving the beautiful balance between introspection and grandeur; straddling the place where pain and hope intersect.

80
Exclaim!

While the title suggests De Augustine's third full-length album is full of sepulchral tones, Tomb has a lightness to it. De Augustine is immersed in love throughout, so while he's working through tough stuff, we are ultimately left with the feeling that De Augustine is growing stronger and that love will bloom again.

80
Uncut

Overall there's a warmth lacking on last year's lo-fi Swim Inside The Moon ... Elsewhere, echoes of Bon Iver and label boss Sufjan Stevens suffuse "All Your Life," his rejection of suicide, while "Time's" whistled melody confirms his latent optimism.

80
Northern Transmissions

Tomb is truly meant for everyone with a personal ax to grind. Retrospection rules.

80
Q Magazine

Dreamy and heartaching, its appearance is actually deceptive ... A gorgeous record.

75
The 405

Rather than allowing grief or bitterness to well up and overwhelm him, he instead uses his music as a vehicle to not only cope, but to also find some sense of reconciliation. On that end, Tomb doesn’t compartmentalize any lingering sense of doubt or despair so much as it comes to terms with those feelings, giving De Augustine some much-needed perspective and the chance to embrace the brighter possibilities that lie ahead.

73
Pitchfork

Despite being his most polished full-length to date, Tomb shows him at his most candid and introspective.

73
Paste

By adding cleaner production, synth and string flourishes alongside poppier and catchier refrains, De Augustine largely hits the mark on Tomb. With a few curveballs thrown throughout, the warm and comforting lull of Swim Inside the Moon is long gone, replaced by a fascinating record that updates his prior work without losing any of its intimacy.

60
Mojo

More blood on the tracks might have upped the ante, but as it stands Tomb is still a gorgeous wallow, with producer Doveman's minimalist touches left to indicate cracks in the facade.

50
God Is in the TV
If we’re all on some crowded, fractious Network Rail-style journey from womb to tomb, then Angelo De Augustine’s new album is almost disembarking from the crowded carriage and trudging towards a rail-replacement bus service. It’s definitely a document of a life that’s suffered something between leaves on the line and derailment.
WatersUnfold
74

#100 FAVOURITE ALBUM OF THE 2010S

Now, I can understand if the similarities to Sufjan Stevens brings this album down, That's completely acceptable. I can not deny the similarities, and this is far from a perfect album. Very very, Very far. Some moments here feel unnecessary and a lot of the songwriting can feel uncomfortable at times, and the production choices like the drum on "I Could Be Wrong" can even ruin the actual beauty beneath it. But that aside, this album is great.

This ... read more

Jonathan00
74

Sufjan de augustine

JayCrackers
83

An album i actually missed in 2019. So glad, i decided to check it out. yes the element of Sufjan Stevens are there but for me Angelo has enough distinctive in sound and lyrics to separate himself from the god of folk, and sets his own sound of beautifully lush melodies and a nice soothing voice with lyrics which become more introspective the further down the record. Honestly, a great record and I wonder what he'll do next.

Track Review

Tomb 8.5/10
All to the Wind 8/10
You Needed Love, I ... read more

More popular reviews
CaNiTi
86

As the culmination of his evolution as an artist and the fullest expression of his sound, Tomb is, without a doubt, a step forward in Angelo De Augustine’s career. Personally, my favorite.

With deeply personal, mature, and poetic lyricism, a simple yet effective production, and an enveloping instrumentation, this is the project that finally frees itself from the weight Augustine carried over from his previous two albums. Each track feels measured, deliberate, and brought to a close at ... read more

tinnaaaj
73

shoutout to albums with old pictures as covers, gotta be one of my favorite genders

carlosfax
70

It's not perfect by any means, but it's still a breathtaking album that I really enjoy listening to every now and then to unwind and relax. I understand why people say he sounds too much like Sufjan, but honestly why is that even an issue? That's not a reason to rate the album any lower imo, especially if the music is as nice as it is. The whole album is so minimalistic and sparse, but I think that's what makes it special; it's built around that along with Angelo's ... read more

More recent reviews
Purchasing Tomb from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

June Playlist