Green and Gray

Critic Score
Based on 5 reviews
2019 Ratings: #424 / 816
User Score
Based on 129 ratings
2019 Ratings: #519
May 3, 2019 / Release Date
LP / Format
Pile, Kevin McMahonProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

80
Exclaim!

At 53 blurry, delirious minutes, it's a lot to take in ... But it's a strong step forward, and offers no more or less than exactly what Pile are all about.

79
Pitchfork

The seventh album from the Boston noise-rock band revels in a heightened level of studio ambition without losing its snarling ferocity.

70
AllMusic

Pile hold on to all the anxiety and fury of youth here, but present their dissonant squalls with a mature, metered patience that just adds to the slow-boiling listening experience.

65
The 405

This is a more palatable and approachable record. But what’s missing is a lot of risk, something that each Pile record has revelled in.

SnowyFighter
80

This👏 Band👏 Is👏 Fire👏

Everything about this band excites me, I wasn’t expecting enjoy this record as much as I did. For some reason I’m deciding to kind of go in a reverse order through Pile’s discography, and Green and Gray is a lot more heavy and direct than their newest record. I’ve also heard their album Dripping and it kind of reminds me a lot of their roots in that sense. It’s somewhat lofi but also still punchy and produced well. Firewood is a ... read more

lincoln
100

I listened to this maybe like a week or two ago? And it instantly took over my top song, top album, and top artist of July. Like, INSTANTLY. Why?? Cus this album is fucking AMAZING. Like seriously. The beauty is in the fusions of art rock and noise rock and math rock and post-hardcore and post rock and any and all measures of indie music in general. The whole nigh-50 minute is chock full of everything, whether it be moody wallowing burnout anthems or raging chaotic noisy bangers, on top of Rick ... read more

usedtobe
90

“First your heart pounds in the dark, in the morning your mouth full of dust."

Cohesive and diverse return with a strikingly well done set of tracks that ranges from sprawling to pummeling, atmospheric to sublime. A big yes to this.

More popular reviews
noob_spoons123
60

I don’t get the hype. I’m sorry y’all.

hsmith2112
90

Favorite Tracks: Firewood, Hiding Places, Hair, No Hands, A Labyrinth with No Center, The Soft Hands of Stephen Miller, On a Bigger Screen

Least Favorite Track: Other Moons

hausenger
30

acceptable, ★★

More recent reviews
Purchasing Green and Gray from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist