Stranger Things

Critic Score
Based on 21 reviews
2016 Ratings: #833 / 1030
User Score
Based on 71 ratings
February 26, 2016 / Release Date
LP / Format
Mamé / Label
Indie Rock / Genre
Max BloomProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

82
Paste

Yuck is a testament to the idea that music doesn’t need to be incredibly innovative to be original.

80
DIY

Though the London band don’t exactly attack in a fist-raised blaze of mega-riffs, they hit hard all the same with quick, sharp, and consistently executed blows of effortless songwriting.

80
The 405

Unlike its predecessor, the new album is expressed with a confident ease rather than pent up frustration. If Glow & Behold detailed the tumultuous break up period for YUCK, then Stranger Things sees the band reach a positively fresh stage of letting go.

70
musicOMH

For all of Stranger Things’ plus points – and there are many – it does occasionally get drawn into a sort of purgatory between the old and the new Yuck.

70
SPIN

This third batch has something to prove, and Bloom makes the most of it, stutter-riffing his best Toadies impression on “Hearts in Motion” and sneaking the timeless gorgeousness of Sebadoh’s “Too Pure” into “Down.”

70
AllMusic

It vaults them back into the noise pop/shoegaze conversation, where they seem poised to stay for a good long while.

65
Under the Radar

If we're talking Yuck 2.0, it's an improvement over Glow. The onerous production choices are gone. In that way, it echoes the first version of the band in a facile sense, and Yuck is still mining the same '90s influences.

65
The Line of Best Fit

This album is a far cry from the 90’s American college-radio rock of their Blumberg-indebted debut, but, for a seemingly make or break record, Stranger Things just doesn’t really take enough risks. 

60
Exclaim!

There's an overemphasis on influences here that makes Stranger Things more recognizably likeable than imaginative.

60
NOW Magazine

Stranger Things deftly runs through musical trends once popular, then killed off and now in vogue again, like shoegaze and noodly Britpop. Aside from flailing a bit at the end, the London group’s third full-length hits its mark.

60
PopMatters

Fans are sure to find something charming about it, as Yuck remain a capable, enjoyable band. However, they seem to have lost the plot a bit with this one.

58
Consequence of Sound

Adequacy is a trait that fits Stranger Things well. It’s not a disappointment like Glow & Behold, but then it only occasionally manages to reach the heights of Yuck’s debut.

52
Pitchfork

Yuck have always invited comparisons to other bands, but these days, the one that flatters them the least is the comparison to themselves.

50
No Ripcord

A passable third LP, but it’s a cheap copy of the original.

40
Mojo
30
Slant Magazine

Stranger Things is often little more than a poor imitation of the band's earlier sound.

MeFromMe
51

Tries to repeat what LP1 did, Yr Face is great but an obvious clone of Rubber

56

Random Rock/Metal LP #4 - Stranger Things by Yuck

This is my 4th review in this series. The point of this series is to find new and interesting music as a Rock and Metal fan. For this series I won't count intro's and outro's if they are listed as such, but they will get lower scores overall, unless it is an intended instrumental and not just a transition or intro/outro.

Hold Me Closer - 66/100
Cannonball - 68/100
Like A Moth - 62/100
Only Silence - 65/100
Stranger Things - ... read more

Blargg
50

So disappointing to see what happened to a once great band here. I'll enjoy a riff or melody here or there on this album, but none of the songs have the ability to take those good elements and really make something of them. There's a serious lack of tension in these songs, none of which have any truly satisfying or cathartic moments. Verses, choruses, and other parts of a song all serve their role, but I am never left on the edge of my seat waiting for that killer moment in a song to ... read more

More popular reviews
Purchasing Stranger Things from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist