It’s definitely not great, but I appreciate Carti’s evolution as an artist even more after hearing this
Not as bad as some people make it out to be, but it’s definitely disappointing and below Kanye’s standards
Great collab album from Kanye & Cudi. Same deal as with ye, could’ve been a little longer. I like their chemistry way more than Kanye & Jay on Watch the Throne. Also, Freeee is way overrated for me.
Great album. I wish it was a bit longer, but we got KSG the same year, so I can’t really complain. Ghost Town and Violent Crimes are both probably in my top 20 Kanye songs.
Another amazing album from Kanye, would’ve been even better if Send It Up and I’m In It weren’t on it. The second half of New Slaves is one of the best-sounding pieces of music of all time. Also, Guilt Trip is underrated, easily top 3 on the album.
New Day being rated only 77 is criminal, easily one of the best on this album, if not the best. Overall, great project, but I expected more from a Jay & Kanye collab
I can’t deny its influence, but musically Kanye has way stronger projects. Still, it’s a great album though.
Even though it’s an amazing album and Kanye is one of my favorite artists of all time, I just can’t listen to some of these songs anymore. This one and MBDTF really grew off me. Back then, I could play the whole thing start to finish with no complaints (maybe except DAHG, which is just pretty boring and repetitive), but now if I hear Good Morning, Stronger, I Wonder, Barry Bonds, or Flashing Lights, I’m skipping immediately. I still think they’re great songs, they just ... read more
Definitely the best album from the College trilogy, and probably my favorite Kanye album overall
Amazing debut album. I don’t really go back to the big hits like All Falls Down, Jesus Walks, or Through the Wire that often anymore, but Family Business gotta be one of my top 5 songs ever, and top 1 Kanye track for me.
It’s not just my favorite album from the whole trilogy, it’s one of my favorite albums of all time. Everything about it is perfect to me: rapping, production, consistency, melodies, replay value. WTF SMH is bringing the overall score a bit down, but it’s still an amazing song. I’m truly impressed that Nas is able to drop a masterpiece like this almost 30 years after Illmatic and It Was Written.
Create an account to rate and review albums.
Recent Review Comments
On Lil Uzi Vert - Eternal Atake 2
"@2CLASSIFIED2 Tbh idk either. While I’m listening to these songs I’m aware that almost every single aspect of them is garbage, but somehow all that garbage put together ends up sounding good and catchy"
On ROSALÍA - MOTOMAMI
"@javier I don’t speak spanish so I was judging whether it’s generic solely based on the sound. If you say it’s not generic at all, I can check out the video but despite the message I don’t know if I’ll give this album a higher rating because I just don’t enjoy how it sounds"
On ROSALÍA - MOTOMAMI
"@Joseaee So nowadays having a different opinion than yours means that I'm stupid? You can’t force me to enjoy the album. If you rated one of my favorite albums 0/100, I wouldn’t insult you because it’s your own music taste"
On ROSALÍA - MOTOMAMI
"@Joseaee You must have felt personally offended by my review to write something so stupid"
On ROSALÍA - MOTOMAMI
"@bradhorvat the worst album I've ever listened to ≠ the worst album of all time"
On ROSALÍA - MOTOMAMI
"@bradhorvat The lack of reading literacy these days is crazy"
On ROSALÍA - LUX
"@grinspng I'm calling it overrated based on the gap between my score and the user score"
On ROSALÍA - MOTOMAMI
"@javier I don’t know a better word to describe songs like Candy or La Fama for example"
On Kendrick Lamar - GNX
"@gurupopuri True, wacced out murals and man at the garden are perfect examples of GNX songs that just keep getting better over time. They used to be some of my least favorites when the album dropped, and now they’re both easily top 5 for me. The title track gnx has grown on me a bit too, though I’m still not really a fan of the features on it."
Advertisement