Critic Score
Based on 20 reviews
2009 Ratings: #824 / 961
User Score
Based on 64 ratings
2009 Ratings: #430
July 7, 2009 / Release Date
LP / Format
XL / Label
Electropop / Genre
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

91
A.V. Club
While it probably won’t become a Postal Service-level phenomenon, the band’s debut album has positioned itself as the kind of top-shelf pool-party jam that people tend to look for around this time of year.
86
Pretty Much Amazing
What Discovery have made is an album that is pop music of the highest caliber – bright and electronic and romantic, danceable, full of effects and production tricks, all these adorable lyrics like “I did your laundry while you slept.” I’ve asked this question before and I’ll ask it again: What’s wrong with that?
85
FACT Magazine

If nothing else, LP should be admired for the way it eschews most modern indie (and especially side projects)’s penchant for flitting around music’s margins – touching on greatness, but never quite going for it – and instead aims straight for the jugular, every chance it gets.

80
Tiny Mix Tapes

Unique and easily-liked, their debut borrows tricks from the pop charts to make songs with both hook and soul. Although bordering on bubblegum, LP is sunny enough for January, as well as July.

80
AllMusic
Overall, the feeling you get from the record is that of a couple of guys having an incredibly fun time creating music that has absolutely no socially redeeming values at all.
80
Spectrum Culture

A clean, expertly crafted, saccharin pop record that provides that rare blend of Top 40 appeal and indie aesthetic. LP glows like midnight under Tokyo lights.

80
Billboard
The combination of Miles’ bright auto-tune vocals and Batmanglij’s impressive work on the synthesizer prove to be a successful pairing
70
NME

A Vampire Weekend hip-hop side project? Sounds crazy, but it's one beautiful fusion.

68
Pitchfork
Vampire Weekend keyboardist Rostam Batmanglij and Ra Ra Riot singer Wes Miles put their own spin on modern R&B.
60
SPIN
Goofy lyrics and too-frequent Auto-Tuning pushes this close to winking douchebaggery, but not too close.
60
Rolling Stone
These guys build R&B; jams with hand claps, 808 whomps and T-Pain-style vocals like hyperactive kids with a Lego set, piling up fragments into tracks that often don't end so much as just stop.
50
Under the Radar
The debut full-length from Discovery, the long-gestating hipster R&B project from Rostam Batmanglij (Vampire Weekend) and Wes Miles (Ra Ra Riot), is a little boring.
40
Drowned in Sound

While LP should ideally be listened to in the presence of at least one of its makers so you can shriek ”what were you THINKING!?” at them over and over, it’s not a record you can quite bring yourself to actively despise: there’s simply not enough there.

40
The Skinny
It’s a stylistically simple affair, with the innocent-sounding, frequently cut-up vocals backed up by spacey, bubbly samples floating about over syncopated programmed beats, chunky keyboard chords and not a lot else.
40
Consequence of Sound
With the ingredients for a really cool diversion of a side project, the outcome is nothing short of a disappointment.
34
Coke Machine Glow
Discovery seem to channel the very essence of discomfort and provocation, opposing tasteful sensibilities so directly and emphatically that it can do nothing but repel.
30
Sputnikmusic
Fuck Jay-Z. THIS is the death of auto-tune.
20
No Ripcord

LP was destined for failure as soon as Batmanglij and Miles thought an exercise in all that’s bad about pop music was some kind of great idea

20
musicOMH
Whatever quibbles we level at bands we’re unsure of, we should rejoice that albums which exhibit an almost terminal lack of redeeming features populate the release schedules with relative scarcity. Sadly, for Discovery at least, theirs is an album that defiantly shuns the trend.
JohnLouisHoward
80

Rostam and Miles started this project long before their better-known gigs, and the sound alternates between undeveloped snippets and finished songs. the uneven quality makes for strongly divided opinion on the merits of the record, but it's more enjoyable than not and the stronger songs like "Swing Tree" and "Orange Shirt" are top-flight synth-pop.

elegiac
67

rostam's solo project from the early days of vampire weekend led to an album i loved when i was younger. listening back now, it's certainly an inconsistent album with some catchy tracks and some duds as well.

theplaguereview
40

Discovery at it’s best is fun summer music you can turn on and tune out to. It’s quite a nostalgic listen for me personally. It’s a unique album with a cool vision but the execution leaves so much to be desired. Sometimes irritating.

More popular reviews
Purchasing LP from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist