Turtleneck & Chain

Critic Score
Based on 11 reviews
2011 Ratings: #524 / 1068
User Score
Based on 277 ratings
2011 Ratings: #487
May 10, 2011 / Release Date
LP / Format
T-Minus, Chops, Michael Woods, DJ Frank E, ILYA, +10 more...Producer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
A.V. Club

The juxtaposition of white-boy geekiness with swaggering hip-hop posturing forms the core of The Lonely Island’s smart-ass take on pop music, but the trio is also distinguished by obsessive cultural specificity on its sophomore effort, Turtleneck & Chain.

80
The Observer

This second album confirms Andy Samberg and co as talents mighty enough to equal the superstar names that join them in their Saturday Night Live skits.

75
Entertainment Weekly

Now, two years after Incredibad, a debut that collected many of the group’s greatest, previously televised hits, comes Turtleneck & Chain, a perfectly acceptibad follow-up.

72
Spectrum Culture

Turtleneck & Chain shows that the boys in the Lonely Island aren’t solely reliant on viral videos and buzz, but deeply affectionate fans. They don’t make mockeries; they joke because they love.

71
Pitchfork

For the most part, though, these are good songs with jokes in them, not jokes with songs attached.

70
AllMusic
Back once again with the ill behavior, Lonely Island’s second effort is more of the same, which for many means that life is still worth living.
70
Consequence of Sound

This is a comedy album that just happens to have more catchy songs than your average pop radio album.

70
Sputnikmusic

While Turtleneck & Chain, like Incredibad before it, is a tad uneven, The Lonely Island are still largely deserving of admiration.

70
Rolling Stone
SNL‘s pop-parody trio show no sign of running out of impossibly brilliant half-jokes.
50
The Needle Drop

Turtleneck and Chain has some pretty memorable tacks on it, to be honest. Some of these might be the best this comedy rap outfit has ever penned.

40
NME
Continuing to party, but this time with devastating covers from auto-tuned lands.
vivi
98

Another Lonely Island review! And sooner than expected I think!! This album was the first Lonely Island album I listened to, and it has a very special place in my heart (just like the rest of their albums because I love all of them), so I wanted to give it a long review. This is my third super long review for an album of theirs, the first being their debut album, “Incredibad”, and the second being their third album, “The Wack Album”.

Did this review a bit differently! ... read more

TrollFaceReview
75

the most white person album of all time

WillNeot
72

A step up from their first album, still not their peak, that'll be their next work, but here it's just an amazing showing of the boys capacities of comedy and music, ther are some low points, but overall is a good record, can't wait to listen to the next one again.

More popular reviews
Skotix
60

I mean its alright, but holy fuck Classy Skit 1 is so fucking bad, it just doesn't need to exist

78

This that Garfield sex music

FaceBrookeDtCom
48

With a lot of comedy albums, some of the jokes won’t hit, whereas others will. Highlights include Rocky, which sounds like it could’ve been a Weird Al song, and I Just Had Sex. However, then we just have songs like “Trouble on Dookie Island” which really dates the comedy of this album.

More recent reviews
Purchasing Turtleneck & Chain from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist