Nov 8, 2019
72
Early Nicki is to her as early Britney is to Slayyyter, but there's still much to enjoy across the record. All I wanted from her was to prove she was more than a meme rapper and she does that pretty much with ease. A little more needed in the way of song structure as well as carving a more distinct lane (as much as I love "Say So," its disco backdrop feels a bit dialed in), and it's also a shame the modest success of "Juicy" earns it a spot here instead of the far superior ... read more
Oct 28, 2019
55
Last month, I saw Aldous Harding live at Berklee. While I was waiting for the concert to begin, I noticed the guy standing in front of me was blatantly going on Scruff and Grindr every two minutes with no subtlety whatsoever. I know I'm not the only one who holds the phone super close to my chest when going on a dating app in public, so I was kinda fascinated by this guy's boldness. I feel a little guilty that I covertly snapped a photo of him doing it to send to the group chat, but hey, we all ... read more
Oct 25, 2019*
45
Turns out Azealia Banks was ahead of the curve yet again with the whole "release a frequently-delayed project that still sounds rushed and musically bankrupt" thing.

UPDATE 10/26/19: Adding 5 points bc the ending of Follow God made me laugh.
Oct 22, 2019
NR
A friend pointed out that this song is serving some SERIOUS Imogen Heap and wow I can't unhear it. My lizard brain initially gravitated me toward SHYHMF but my sophisti brain said "no, THIS is the one."

That trick on the chorus - repeating a six-beat phrase across an eight-beat measure - is so common yet used so well here. Lyrically, that imagery of one door after another opening, is all the song really needs. That glorious moment at the end of the bridge when she repeats it over a ... read more
Oct 17, 2019
87
Y'all ever tried being gay?? Like, have you ever thought it might make you not approach everything with boring cynicism and allow you to just enjoy music for what it is? Ever taken a second look at stan culture and realized you could be getting genuine enjoyment out of music like them instead of just trying to out-deep the next person??

I bet you'd like it!
Oct 14, 2019
74
Growing a little more with each listen. Don’t have super high expectations for the album but at least we know it won’t be Ryan Adams vainly trying to recreate the Guyville magic long after that train has left the station. The new song she played when I saw her live last year was pretty good too.

Also is there a site like AOTY but for reviewing books? I’m reading Liz’s memoir currently and would like to share my thoughts on it.
Oct 7, 2019
100
Now that end of decade lists are coming out I just want to say that this is probably my favorite song of the 2010s.
Oct 6, 2019
74
Amazing songs Lizzo has been dropping in 2019 (Drake repelling meme)
Just OK song Lizzo dropped two years ago (Drake thumbs up meme)
__________________________________________________

If we’re only talking about singles, Lizzo has literally never released a bad song. Since 2016, her single output has ranged from good (“Fitness”) to great (“Boys”) to flawless (“Juice”).

Yet somehow, the success of this track has brought out my inner curmudgeonly ... read more
Sep 30, 2019*
82
UPDATE: Time to wipe the mascara off and write about this thing for real.

There's this Chinese game show where two people look at an extremely pixelated digital image that is gradually getting better and better resolution, and the first person to guess what it's a picture of wins. Tracking Marnie Stern's output chronologically is kind of like playing that game, and Chronicles of Marnia is where the photo finally comes into view.

I guess it might be easy to write this off as Stern's 'normie' ... read more
Sep 23, 2019
88
How high is the bar set with Joanna Newsom that Divers is considered to be a disappointment by some in her fanbase??

The biggest thing going against this album is that it's just that: an album - not a three-disc American songbook epic, not a five-track baroque pop masterclass whose shortest song is over seven minutes - just a standard eleven-track album. For some, this already reduces potential enjoyment simply because it seems less ambitious in scope. Good thing Newsom really brings it with ... read more
Sep 17, 2019
76
My office moved locations and my new lease doesn't start till October 1. It's on the other side of the state and the commute is hellish. Good prep for if I ever decide to move to LA I guess.

Anyway I had a lot of fun listening to this while stuck in endless traffic on the pike yestterday. Johnny Venus and Doctur Dot are clearly still honing their craft but bring a lot of great ideas to the table. The Outkast comparisons escape me since what made Outkast great was the juxtaposition of Andre's ... read more
Sep 15, 2019
82
Have a sore throat this morning from screaming along to this at her concert last night along with the entirety of greater Boston area Stan Twitter.

If I’m being honest, this is one of the only songs from Eden I’d consider to be a Tier 1 Cupcakke track. The flow is focused and consistent - honestly there are times I think her braggadocious songs can eclipse the raunchy tracks she’s known for. I’m not sure if it was ever confirmed whether or not someone from PC Music had ... read more
Sep 12, 2019
44
The worst part is this is a pretty interesting concept that could have come out way better if more effort was put into the structuring, production, and composition. Producer Boiling Energy brings a few good ideas, but the mix job needs a lot of work. Banks's vocals are at times way too loud, way too quiet, or needing to be scrapped entirely.

There are fleeting moments where her flow is original, innovative, and even funny ("Gay! Gay! Gay!" she yells at one point, describing DL men), ... read more
Sep 10, 2019
93
One of her most underrated singles. I love the sharp strings and grand, strutting drums are that make me want to model-walk around the house when no one's home. There's also just so much power commanded in the minor-key verses that makes the melt into the gorgeous emotional chorus even more rewarding. The sentiment of the song is tried and true (plus a little depressing now since it's probably about Kendu) but gosh I can feel the sincerity.
Sep 4, 2019
53
Turns out he 100% ruined this song.
Sep 3, 2019
74
"Bad Year" has been my theme song for the entirety of 2019 tbh.

Fun if somewhat generic indie rock album for people who can't do anything but laugh at their predicaments. Fans of earlier Broken Social Scene will enjoy.
Sep 3, 2019
82
Now it's time for her to seal the deal and do a comeback performance of these songs on SNL.
Sep 3, 2019
78
因为我的老板不说英语,所以我学了跟简单的汉语为了跟他交流。虽然我觉得我没有合适的词汇为了形容这样的音乐,但是为了欢迎我们的从中国来的歌迷,我会尽量用中文评价这个专辑。这是我自己写的,没有谷歌翻译的帮助。

这是Lana Del Rey第五个专辑(如果你包括“Lizzy ... read more
Aug 28, 2019
57
I remember in 2013-2014 there seemed to be an unspoken arms race between Azealia Banks, Iggy Azalea, and Angel Haze about who was going to get their record out first. The task seemed impossible - with Nicki still at her imperial phase and the prevailing narrative about female rappers being that there was "only room for one" (as hip-hop critic Elizabeth Mendez-Berry put it - let's get embedded links on this site!), record labels had especially high expectations for up-and-coming ... read more
Aug 15, 2019*
42
Ashamed to say i was /kinda/ rooting for her with this project. We love an underdog story, even for someone who seems to deliberately ignore and misinterpret valid critiques about performance of "urban-ness" (see: "Clap Back"). Plus the pre-release singles were absolute bops. The final product, however, is just too spare, too unambitious, to really meet the comeback she's allegedly been slated for.

The "I'm my own artist now" record, especially following years of ... read more
Create an account to rate and review albums.
Recent Review Comments
On EvilFox's review of Doja Cat - Hot Pink
"We stan Say So"
On Doofly's review of Frank Ocean - In My Room
"feels like the unpleasant personality we all know he has in real life is finally starting to bleed into his music "
On angelxcx's review of Grimes - Miss_Anthrop0cene
"good"
On FlamingoSingles's review of Big Thief - Not
"Was the song I was looking forward to the least solely because of its runtime but wound up being my favorite song on the album.,"
On Grimes - Miss_Anthrop0cene
"ty for feedback. album still not good. "
On JohnLouisHoward's review of Angel Olsen - All Mirrors
"^ same - not since "Enemy" from BYFFNW have I been this enamored with one specific song of hers"
On Liz Phair - Good Side
"I think it was called “The Game,” I just remember liking her acoustic guitar part in it "
On okcomputer12127's review of Various Artists - Matilda the Musical (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
"I can see why you feel this way. Thanks for all the likes and positivity you've sent my way - hoping you take the time you need but also looking forward to when you get back. "
On Perfume Genius - Put Your Back N 2 It
"Yep - as much as I love maximalist Mike and am so pumped to see The Sun Still Burns Here I think this will always be my personal favorite PG album. "
On Marnie Stern - The Chronicles of Marnia
"@musicmagpie55 thanks yeah I'm good. This year's just been like one crazy thing happening after another. "
On JoaoSantos's review of Charli XCX - Charli
"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvZs1QbV_3A"
On Plats's review of Pixies - Beneath the Eyrie
"Had to look up where Meghan Trainor's from and of course it's Cape Cod. "
On exception's review of Azealia Banks - Yung Rapunxel II
"This depresses me more with each listen bc it just shows how much she’s regressed as an artist. 2012-2014 Azealia would have killed this concept."
On Space Vacation's review of Lana Del Rey - Norman Fucking Rockwell!
"*sofia vergara voice* she finally dead"
On Lana Del Rey - Fuck it I love you / The greatest
"Still two slots unscheduled. Ever since the disastrous 2012 performance it seems like she's very hesitant to do any TV appearances but I think the critical acclaim of this record means now's as good a time as any. I would settle for a knockout performance of The Greatest on Fallon though - the straights would be shook. "
On lermontov's review of Liz Phair - Liz Phair
"OH BABY KNOW WHAT UR LIKE? UR LIKE MY FAVORITE UNDERWEAR IT JUST FEELS RIGHT!!!! YOU KNOW IT!!!!!"
On Inglume's review of Помни Имя Свое - Небо и Камень
"*mariah carey voice* loving that concept!"
On amw100's review of Sleater-Kinney - The Center Won't Hold
"Astute - specifically the word “light” on the chorus of Ruins... it’s almost like they’re deliberately singing a semitone apart from each other. It’s the yelling on this song that really undoes it for me. "
On Alison Krauss - I've Got That Old Feeling
"Will put on So Long, So Wrong now. Thanks for the recommendations and feedback friends <3 "
On Amanda Palmer - There Will Be No Intermission
"It’s not the kind of album you can digest easily, but it clearly was not meant to be. Given the long gestation period, this project couldn’t have been anything but a grand statement, perhaps even difficult to swallow in places. Sometimes the performer needs an intermission just as much as the listener. "
On Amanda Palmer - There Will Be No Intermission
"If Theatre is Evil’s biggest problem was a lack of quality control across its 15 tracks, There Will Be No Intermission’s might be songs that are a little bit too tended to. The less-showy, less-robust instrumentation means the listener, for better or for worse, has no choice but to zero in on the lyrics, which often delivered at a very relaxed pace. The record doesn’t actually run that much longer than 2012’s Theatre is Evil, but feels an eon longer. "
On Amanda Palmer - There Will Be No Intermission
"s into their own universes."
On Amanda Palmer - There Will Be No Intermission
"Even the overall format of There Will Be No Intermission, which bookends each song with instrumental interludes, seems to contradict the actual title (Palmer acknowledges this with the title of the final interlude: “Intermission is Relative”). These interludes, mostly spacy atmospheric reprises of melodies from the main songs, are unobtrusive - you could cut all of them and still have nearly 70 minutes of material - but they easily fulfill what appears to be their purpose of siloing the ten song"
On Amanda Palmer - There Will Be No Intermission
"Throughout the record, Palmer provides an interesting paradox by offering philosophical musings while also leaning into her own contradictions. She displays a blase attitude towards material possessions on “The Thing About Things,” but then frets over Martignetti’s left-behind belongings a few songs later on “Machete.” She displays near-suicidal outlook on opener “The Ride” but encourages life on songs like “Voicemail for Jill.”"
On Amanda Palmer - There Will Be No Intermission
"She cries. She recalls the last time she called him (the third instance on the album that deals in calling the deceased). The climax feels a little forced, but the sentiment is real (seriously though, check out that 2016 version)."

October Playlist
Forums
Vinyl Me, Please