Voices

Critic Score
Based on 19 reviews
2014 Ratings: #579 / 1066
User Score
Based on 347 ratings
2014 Ratings: #307
February 18, 2014 / Release Date
LP / Format
Republic / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

91
Entertainment Weekly

On their second disc, the pair crank out newly groovy space-age bachelor-pad music: Swirling stutter steps like first single “Fall in Love” and “Howling at the Moon” sound downright ferocious, without sacrificing the gauzy, lovely ache at Voices’ center.

85
Paste

Voices is one of the most exciting sad albums I’ve encountered in a while. And it triumphs in that space in between.

80
Northern Transmissions
Phantogram finally sounds the way Phantogram has always wanted to sound, and a large part of that comes from tighter and smarter compositions.
80
PopMatters

With their newest album the New York based duo have turned from a promising indie-rock group into a full-fledged, ass kicking, genre-mashing superhero team.

80
SPIN

What makes this upstate New York duo’s darkness uniquely compelling is their seamless blending of hip-hop influences with horror-film beats, which insures that their particular brand of brooding is complex and surprising, instead of simply sullen.

75
A.V. Club

As a whole, Voices is a huge step forward for the band, one that smartly amplifies its atmospheric gifts through the lens of worthy songs.

75
Pretty Much Amazing

Phantogram makes music for when the disco ball is still hanging, and the speakers are still blaring, but the dance floor has emptied out, and the confetti is swept away.

75
Under the Radar

Phantogram shows a marked improvement in song conceptualization with Voices. Less fat goes a long way for the kind of weight this duo brings to each track.

70
Drowned in Sound
Brass tacks time again: it's because the songwriting is a bit less interesting than before, maybe a conscious concession to claim a more middle ground audience.
70
AllMusic

After making some noise with their debut album, Eyelid Movies, which straddled the line between trip-hop and shoegaze with the skill of an acrobat, Phantogram have refined and expanded their sound in really interesting ways.

67
Consequence of Sound

At times it sounds like Eyelid Movies Part Deux, which for some fans might be its strongest suit. But Phantogram fans hoping the group would dive deep into new, unexplored territory will come away wanting more.

65
Spectrum Culture
With an accessible sound that doesn’t feel formulaic, Phantogram have a bright future. They may even be on the verge of a definitive record. Wonder how many soundtracks they’ll appear on before that happens.
60
DIY
A fearless, hands-on approach to the rebirth of trip-hop through the eyes of two New Yorkers.
60
The Line of Best Fit

Voices comes to a graceful if unsatisfying close with the mournful ache of “My Only Friend,” a somber number that unfortunately takes too long to reveal its intentions and ultimately ends up missing much of its moment entirely, like much of the record itself.

60
Pitchfork

As much as Voices tries to get in your head, it too easily recedes to back of mind.

60
The Observer

Occasionally,, mostly when Carter sings, Voices falls flat, but Phantogram's audacity is commendable.

50
No Ripcord
With time and luck, they’ll emerge more focused and innovative with the commanding intent to please their fans and silence the voices of their critics.
50
Slant Magazine

Voices rarely has a chance to establish any momentum before getting tripped up by its own inconsistency.

IrisThirdEye
83

wow, what an album! what a treat to listen. being textured and detailed, this is as good as production can possibly be.

overall, the album may be frontloaded, as the first three tracks are just too good. although, as a whole it’s a solid sophomore project.

Phantogram seemingly can’t get emotional without getting electronic: no emo without electro.

troubled vocals are double tracked as “nothing but trouble” begins Phantogram’s sophomore effort with a ... read more

Host
95

One of the most underrated albums of all time?!?!
This is so fucking good what the hell 😭😭😭

sleighbell
80

“Voices”
Phantogram
2014

this is a really good album that doesn’t enough love nowadays. listen to it!

BEST: Black Out Days, Fall In Love, Never Going Home, Bill Murray, I Don’t Blame You, Celebrating Nothing

More popular reviews
Rubycap
90

A more consistent, energetic, and punchy follow up to it’s predecessor.

83

It’s a shame that I haven’t checked out this album sooner. All these years hearing “Black Out Days” on every edit I can think of, I didn’t realize they made it. After hearing it fully, what a track. This album is so creative. It’s impressive how they balance dark and light sounds, creating a different mood for each song. Plenty of tracks where I need to hear them live. An album worth listening to

Favorites: Black Out Days, Fall In Love, Nothing But Trouble, ... read more

nutellalvr
100

- if you haven't listened to phantogram what the actual FUCK are u doing get real..
- i do think that some of their intros can be kinda long or boring maybe???? so maybe some ppl just skip it or smth i could neva
- i think this album is so perfect. "nothing but trouble" is the PERRRFECT start and "my only friend" is the perfect end
- i know "fall in love" is one of their most popular songs (rightfully so) but no one gave a shit abt it until tiktok found it.. ... read more

More recent reviews
Purchasing Voices from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

Year End Lists

#30/Paste

More Lists
Comments (2)
Sign in to comment
2w
5mo

June Playlist