Critic Score
Based on 16 reviews
2010 Ratings: #147 / 948
User Score
Based on 384 ratings
2010 Ratings: #184
May 25, 2010 / Release Date
LP / Format
Wild NothingWriter
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

82
Pitchfork

Though some of indie's brightest leading men have come through Virginia's halls of higher education (Steve Malkmus, David Berman, Travis Morrison), your average college rock band in the Old Dominion area probably sounds more like Agents of Good Roots. So if you live in a place like Blacksburg, Va., home of the Virginia Tech campus and not much else, and you want to be in a tropical punk act (Facepaint), an introspective singer-songwriter project (Jack & the Whale), or a band that covers Kate Bush instead of Dave Matthews (Wild Nothing's breakthrough rendition of "Cloudbusting"), you'll probably have to do what Jack Tatum did and start them yourself.

80
AllMusic
Tatum’s ability to create a mood of quiet desperation is so perfectly calibrated that you wouldn’t want to change a thing sound-wise.
70
musicOMH

Music tends to follow the general rule of thumb that if you can get three examples of something then it can be called a trend. Only in music it's called a genre, and it usually ends up slowly ruining the thing it's supposed to be defining. You get the feeling that as 'chillwave' slowly becomes shorthand for everything vaguely summery or a little bit hazy, that in amongst the shimmering keyboards and padded drums you can make out the death knell.

70
PopMatters

If all you heard was a set of iTunes samples of Wild Nothing’s debut Gemini, you might think you were listening to a nostalgic playlist of ‘80s and ‘90s Anglo alt-rock, spanning post-punk, 4AD art-noise, proto-Britpop, and shoegaze. New Order, the Cure, the Cocteau Twins, the Stone Roses, My Bloody Valentine—their signature sounds all appear in some form or another on Gemini via mastermind Jack Tatum’s canny reconstructions of those iconic groups’ easily recognizable styles.

70
The Needle Drop
On Wild Nothing's debut LP, singer-songwriter Jack Tatum follows the path laid out before him by his dreampop forefathers. He doesn't exactly make his own mark, but if you're looking for a sincere and passionate reenactment of 80s indie pop, lay your ears on this album pronto.
kaytra_nada777
100

an absolutely seminal dream pop record from one of the most underrated groups of the last decade wild nothing have been making masterpieces in the underground for a minute now

Doofy
72

I think I'm hearing this with different ears to when I first tried this album out in 2010.

I've listened to a lot more music and have a lot more reference points - so as much as I detected some obvious '80s reference points back then (the usual New Order, Cure, Joy Division, etc) I now hear more of his contemporaries...and of course, given the gift of hindsight, the artists who followed.

So now I play this and instantly think 'Elvis Depressedly, John Maus, Ariel Pink' - among others. As such ... read more

hpianomusic
70

Just as enjoyable as Nocturne.

More popular reviews
blickrosssssss
83

some very spacy and dreamy bedroom pop songs on here with a little bit of jangle pop sprinkled onto these instrumentals, love the the instrumental on bored games, sounds like an arcade/disco banger, the claps and the 808s are cool and the rising synths are very nice touch, prob one of my favs on this record, all of these songs aim to sound more ethereal and bigger than earth rather than trying to sound dark and dark like the cover suggests, but in some way the dark and eerie aesthetic of the ... read more

Adam3ds
59

It feels kind of stale and boring.

dmentime
66

Not bad just boring. You kind of know how the entire song goes from the first 30 seconds.

More recent reviews
Purchasing Gemini from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

June Playlist