Open Your Heart

Critic Score
Based on 26 reviews
2012 Ratings: #49 / 1141
Year-End Rank: #41
User Score
Based on 171 ratings
2012 Ratings: #242
March 6, 2012 / Release Date
LP / Format
Sacred Bones / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
A.V. Club

Compared to Leave Home’s murky smear of scream-fueled, shoegaze-shrouded punk, Open Your Heart is practically a party album.

90
No Ripcord

The Men’s Open Your Heart has the good sense to utilize its influences as a means to go forward, cultivating an eclectic albeit consistent brand of independent rock n’ roll music.

89
Beats Per Minute

It rages, rages more, tapers off, creeps up behind you, knocks your block off, takes a step back, then does those last two simultaneously – and that’s just the first half of the album.

85
Pitchfork

Open Your Heart is both tremendously physical and friendly, knocking you on your ass one second, then immediately helping you back up to put a beer in your hand.

80
Under the Radar

With Open Your Heart, the group refine things just enough

80
Consequence of Sound

The Men may not be hailed as the genre’s saviors, nor should they be, but here they have done an excellent job as its purveyors.

80
NME

Overall, ‘Open Your Heart’ is breezier and more tuneful than its predecessor, but this is very relative.

70
The 405

The Men have crafted a wonderfully accessible record with increased focus and improved song writing, even if there is still more to be developed upon

70
Drowned in Sound

Even if it’s over-seasoned with idolatry, there’s still an awful lot to like about this record, and more than a few moments to love.

60
Mojo
60
PopMatters

At the end of the day, the Men aren’t quite all they’re cracked up to be, but even a bitter cynic like me has to admit, this album is worth a listen.

EthanW
78

This was a surprisingly good album. If not good, it's solid at the very least. There's pretty good song progression on the majority of these tracks, and this project includes a couple of good transitions. The vocals can be hit or miss, but usually, they hit. I have no idea what was going on with track 2, both the lyrics and vocals were subpar, and it's definitely the worst track on here. The tracks all do a good job at staying consistent with the theme, and overall the album was executed well. ... read more

Raiksheen
80

Great

50

Mediocre.

More popular reviews
ace_the_creator
72

most songs were ok, none too noteworthy fav-candy

Cairns
90

this is my pick for the quintessential, modern American rock-n-roll album

100

perfect post hardcore indie punk mush to pickle yourself to

More recent reviews
Purchasing Open Your Heart from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist