Critic Score
Based on 16 reviews
2000 Ratings: #8 / 253
User Score
2000 Ratings: #5All Time: #101
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
Drowned in Sound

Put simply, 'Since I Left You' is this year's 'Odelay', this year's 'Homework'; oh, to hell with it, Album of the Year so far - it's such a dead cert I had to use capitals. 

100
Tiny Mix Tapes

Simply put: Since I Left You is a brilliant collage of music, brilliantly pasted together.

100
AllMusic

There's little doubt to Since I Left You's status as one of the most intimate and emotional dance records that isn't vocal-based.

95
Pitchfork

The Avalanches have managed to build a totally unique context for all these sounds, while still allowing each to retain its own distinct flavor. As a result, Since I Left You sounds like nothing else.

90
NME

The Avalanches have found their irreverent, bittersweet take on pop turned into one of the albums of the year.

90
SPIN

With no gaps between its 18 tracks, just a relentless party groove, Since I Left You is so madly glad, it’s demented ... Gravity, in every sense, is abandoned. Go with their flow.

90
Sputnikmusic

Beautifully mixes up hundreds of third-party compositions into something somehow greater than the sum of its parts.

90
RapReviews.com
This album does require an open mind, not unlike when you first listened to The Roots — remember that? — or a Swizz beat — like “Money, Cash, Hoes” or, better yet, “Ruff Ryders Anthem.” Don’t worry about that, though. Chances are the first listen will crack your head wide the fuck open anyway.
80
Under the Radar

Since I Left You is a highly enjoyable concoction.

80
Alternative Press

One of the most joyous and poignant party albums ever.

80
The Guardian
British producers should take notes.
80
Q Magazine
A record that finally fulfils sampling's original promise of generating fabulous new sounds from skilfully lifted bits of existing tracks.
75
Entertainment Weekly

Every track on their debut is a restless, ever-morphing collage of R&B, pop, and rock samples that continually keeps you off balance.

70
Rolling Stone

Since I Left You is as sunny as an Australian summer, harnessing a wide range of music - soul, hip-hop, warped analog synths, disco, orchestral crescendos - with the new-toy joy of early sampling-based rap and a dance-music sensibility.

70
Slant Magazine
Into Love Boat drug music for fashion runways and neo-hippie gay weddings? Then the Avalanches, Australia’s buzzing dance export, have the disc for you.
60
The Independent
Melbourne's crossover sextet's upbeat ambient pop sounds can be fun and infectious, but overall they draw too heavily on familiar Francophile sounds, as already presented by Daft Punk et al.
jbjohnston2011
100

Okay, what is it with me listening to so many albums that are becoming my favourites of all time on first listen these past few days? I mean, I can’t say it’s a bad thing, but it’s a surprise nonetheless. Considering I’ve listened to this, Bocanada, and Loveless, all in the span of about three weeks, which have all entered in my top 5 favourite albums, is wild to me. Whatever the case, it’s cool to see that I’m finding so much music that I’m enjoying. ... read more

CJay
100

Original Review: Avalanches made this album in a studio... WITH A BUNCH OF SAMPLES
Original Score: 9/10

LAST REVIEW

This may or may not come as a surprise, but yes. This will be my last review on AOTY, and I have a couple of reasons for this decision. One, I'm not as passionate about reviewing as I once was. Some of it is because I've written so many reviews, but a lot of it is because I started to get self-conscious about my writing. To me, I saw it as lazy and uninspired. A lot ... read more

MattsReviews
90

The Avalanches have quite the career, as their quality has always maintained it’s high standard. “Since I Left You” was the start of it all, kickstarting an everlasting journey to creating some of the best pieces of music of all time. Although I prefer it’s successor, “Wildflower’, “Since I Left You” has some interesting ideas and was the first to come from the group, and is undoubtedly a stunning album.

Welcome to my 200th review! Thank you all ... read more

More popular reviews
79

Det var bra, jag gillar den här typen av musik och omslaget är väldigt fint. Det enda negativa var att det ibland upprepade sig lite för mycket och alla ljuden var inte överdrivet najs att höra på. Borde ksk lyssna igen!

portisbraind_89
94

maybe yes, i want a dick

usertakenscarr
85

I mean it's really fun

More recent reviews
Purchasing Since I Left You from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Year End Lists

#3/Pitchfork

More Lists
Sign in to comment
2h
18h
1d
1w
1w

April Playlist