Critic Score
Based on 20 reviews
2003 Ratings: #13 / 442
User Score
2003 Ratings: #40
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
Q Magazine

Pretty much everything a second album needs to be, it's like Is This It but more emotional, more colourful, slightly better.

100
The Observer

Where their debut - from the title's absent question mark onwards - was a kind of energised shrug, their second album is a defiant step forward: the sound of a band at once staying where they ought to be and really getting somewhere.

91
SPIN

Room's similarity to its predecessor ultimately bespeaks a purity of vision, not a dearth of new ideas.

91
Consequence of Sound
The second album from the New York garage rockers is a pivotal step in the bandโ€™s evolution.
90
Drowned in Sound
An adrenaline-fueled head-rush of precision-perfect pop tunes about modern life.
90
Gigwise

A triumph of excellent songwriting and fabulously co-dependant musicianship, ‘Room On Fire’ is the perfect second album: it builds on their early promise whilst developing at a steady enough pace to suggest that they could still get better.

90
Alternative Press
Better than its predecessor.
90
NME
โ€˜Room On Fireโ€™ is a refining and tinkering with The Strokes sound, a carefully calibrated attempt not to fuck up too early in the face of untold temptations. The results are still sleek, sexy and thrilling, with a tantalising promise of even better to come.
90
Tiny Mix Tapes

Room on Fire isn't a huge progression from Is This It?, but it stands as a more polished version of the style that the Strokes have always employed.

83
Coke Machine Glow

Room on Fire ultimately proves itself a worthy successor and by far one of the year's best pop-rock albums.

80
Rolling Stone
In the face of hysterical expectation, the Strokes have resisted the temptation to hit the brakes, grow up and screw around with a sound that doesn't need fixing -- yet.
80
Uncut

His remarkable performance enlivens even the album's most underwhelming passages.

80
Mojo

The Strokes come across as a world-sized band that's tethering itself ... Nonetheless, this record is good.

80
NOW Magazine

If you bought the first album and loved it, you'll probably love Room On Fire just as much.

80
The Independent

The too-obvious (and too constricted) influences discernible on The Strokes' debut have been smoothed and moulded here into something more uniquely theirs, while the comparatively tight focus of Julian Casablancas's lyrical concerns confirms the initial impression that this albums is a more homogenous offering than Is This It.

80
Prefix

He builds atmosphere out of evocative lyrics and emotional scenery, and he does it without leaning on linear narrative or songs with singular interpretations.

80
AllMusic

Some may gripe that it's never as good as the first time, but Room on Fire shows that even after all that happened to the Strokes, they can still surprise.

80
Pitchfork

They may not be able to get away with milking this formula for many more albums, but for now, Room on Fire's eleven songs find them drowsily getting away with what they do best.

75
Entertainment Weekly

Anyone who invested anything in ”Is This It” is destined to walk away from ”Room on Fire” a little disappointed.

60
The Guardian

A roaring opener, a trio of great potential singles and a remarkable slow number successfully divert attention from the fact that half of Room on Fire is uninspired filler.

Tielur
90

The only gripe I have with this record are the long silent sequences between songs.

KandZ
90

โœจReposting my old reviews with MORE detail #3โœจ

Oh Boy!
If I could experience this album for the first time again, I'd be extremely thankful to god!

'Room On Fire' is an amazing follow-up of 'Is This It', it's basically a cousin to this album aswell.
Shortly after 'Is This It''s release, The Strokes were under pressure of delivering an album that would be as good, as the debut... Fun fact, this album would be even better if RCA would allow them ... read more

PipePanic
89

BAND BINGE: THE STROKES (PART 2WO OF 2WENTY1NE)

'I want to be forgotten and I don't want to be reminded.'

This album is the perfect breakup album.

Coming hot, and I mean HOT off the trails of their tour of their debut record (Is This It came out 2001, they toured relentlessly for a year, and in 2003 this came out. Fucking how.), The Strokes wanted to sharpen up their sound. They wanted more experimental mixing, sharper instrumentation, more heartfelt writing and clean cut production for ... read more

More popular reviews
NR

me likey

SaigenTheWhite
70

It's good, but not on the level of the first one.

rowanlikesmusic
99

every bit as good as is this it. the only problem is the silence between the songs

More recent reviews
Purchasing Room on Fire from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

Year End Lists

#3/NME
#3/SPIN
#11/Pitchfork

More Lists
Sign in to comment
3d
3d
1mo
1mo
1mo

June Playlist