Recently Rated

Cate Le Bon - Pompeii
Cate Le Bon
Pompeii
2022 • LP
72
Jan 7, 2023
Belle and Sebastian - A Bit of Previous
Belle and Sebastian
A Bit of Previous
2022 • LP
50
Jan 7, 2023
Punch Brothers - Hell on Church Street
Punch Brothers
Hell on Church Street
2022 • LP
75
Jan 7, 2023
Hatchie - Giving The World Away
Hatchie
Giving The World Away
2022 • LP
83
Jan 7, 2023
Beach House - Once Twice Melody
Beach House
Once Twice Melody
2022 • LP
89
Jan 7, 2023
Arcade Fire - WE
Arcade Fire
WE
2022 • LP
58
Jan 7, 2023
CMAT - If My Wife New I'd Be Dead
CMAT
If My Wife New I'd Be Dead
2022 • LP
82
Jan 7, 2023
Peach Pit - From 2 to 3
Peach Pit
From 2 to 3
2022 • LP
65
Dec 26, 2022
Mitski - Laurel Hell
Mitski
Laurel Hell
2022 • LP
73
Dec 26, 2022
The Swell Season - The Swell Season
The Swell Season
The Swell Season
2006 • LP
83
Dec 26, 2022

Recent Reviews

Cate Le Bon - Pompeii
72

There now seems a clear artistic divide within Cate Le Bon’s discography, between her 2016 LP “Crab Day” and its 2019 followup “Reward.” In the interim, Le Bon turned to self-producing her works, and her already eclectic, quirky brand of art pop turned denser and knottier — though the less accessible output nonetheless earned her an expanded audience and the best press of her career. “Pompeii” sounds a direct continuation of “Reward,” ... read more

Belle and Sebastian - A Bit of Previous
50

Belle and Sebastian are now the better part of two decades removed from what was already a second creative career peak in the mid-aughts, and it’s understandable that the now-54-year-old Stuart Murdoch is no longer writing the best music of his career. That said, the past few Belle and Sebastian releases have taken a particular nosedive in quality — the terribly sleepy 2019 rerecording of “Get Me Away From Here, I’m Dying” spotlighted a band drained of their former ... read more

Punch Brothers - Hell on Church Street
75

As The Punch Brothers’ career has progressed, they’ve become the de facto public face of progressive bluegrass for those less attuned to the scene, partially thanks to the success of their poppier 2015 breakout “The Phosphorescent Blues,” partially due to Chris Thile’s visibility as an NPR host. But after their 2018 LP “All Ashore,” which I found too precious and self-impressed for its own good, The Punch Brothers wisely use “Hell on Church ... read more

Hatchie - Giving The World Away
83

As much as I enjoyed Hatchie’s 2019 debut “Keepsake” for its melodic richness and willing embrace of dream pop’s poppiest instincts, I understood the vocal minority who found the album too bubblegum-polished for its own good — indie pop’s answer to Taylor Swift, before Swift herself tried to become indie pop’s answer to Taylor Swift. Luckily for fans and doubters alike, “Giving the World Away” is an unmistakable artistic progression for ... read more

Beach House - Once Twice Melody
89

Now eight albums into their career, Beach House must be in the conversation of indie rock bands with the all-time most consistent discography. Having long ago passed Steven Hyden’s five-album test, the duo have taken their time between releases but reliably follow through by releasing albums that meet their exceptional standards, simultaneously meeting expectations of how a Beach House album should sound while subtly forging ahead and expanding their scope. Their first double-album, ... read more

About

I basically only listen to things I think I'll like, so my scores skew high. 60 = average, 70 = good, 90+ = all-time fave.

Rating Distribution

100
 
90 - 9948
 
80 - 89452
 
70 - 79538
 
60 - 69353
 
50 - 59123
 
40 - 4934
 
30 - 3912
 
20 - 294
 
10 - 192
 
0 - 92
 
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Recent Lists

This past year I did an absolutely terrible job of keeping up with new music -- and processing what I did hear to the degree the music deserved. I didn't get around to many albums that I ...
Blue RevAnd In The Darkness, Hearts AglowDragon New Warm Mountain I Believe In YouAnts From Up ThereOnce Twice Melody
Updated 3y agoRanked
Favorite Albums of 2021 (as of 12/31/21) Honorable Mentions: Birdy, Black Country, New Road, Cole Chaney, Katy Kirby, Kiwi Jr., Lael Neale, Mac Leaphart, Madi Diaz, Pom Pom Squad, Squirrel Flower, ...
To See the Next Part of the DreamJubileeMercurial WorldHome VideoIgnorance
Updated 4y agoRanked 1
Favorite Albums of 2020 (as of 12/31/20) Honorable Mentions: Andy Shauf, Anna Burch, Annie, Ashley McBryde, Bright Eyes, The Chicks, Eve Owen, Hinds, Jennifer Castle, Johanna Warren, Kacey ...
Fetch the Bolt CuttersPunisherSaint CloudsongsNO DREAM
Updated 5y agoRanked 1
Member since December 26, 2016

April Playlist