I can’t say I hate everything about this but the lyrics are so terribly awful even by Green Day standards. At this album’s best it sounds like Diet Black Keys and at it’s worst it sounds like the cover art which might the worst cover art of all time.

Somewhere in between the quality of the trilogy and their stuff in 90’s. Decent album.

Probably the best of the trilogy. It doesn’t have anything nearly as bad as Fuck Time or Nightlife. Dirty Rotten Bastards is also a pretty decent song.

Has higher highs than Uno like Lazy Bones and Amy but also has lower lows like Fuck Time and Nightlife.

Average but in kind of a painful way. The only word I can use for this album is tolerable. It feels like if an AI made a Green Day album. Where 21st Century Breakdown it at least felt like they were trying, no one on here feels like they care.

Diet American Idiot

Green Day’s most ambitious project and by far their best. All killer no filler. Fantastic album.

Completely fine I guess. It doesn’t experiment with their sound like Nimrod does and it doesn’t have the bangers that Dookie and Insomniac have. Very forgettable middle of the road.

This album is just Dookie but better. Has a much better consistent flow through the songs. The faster tempos and harsher sound really gives this album a lot of flavor to it. Panic Song is an all-time great Green Day song.

Has some great moments on it like Longview, Chump, Basket Case, and Welcome To Paradise. Other than that it’s fine I guess.

Tied with Brand New Eyes as their most consistent and well-written album.

Fun album, on par with the self title.

Highlights: Hard Times, Idle Worship, Told You So, Rose Colored Boy.

Not quite as consistent as Brand New Eyes but still a solid album.

Highlights: Now, Ain’t It Fun, Part II, Last Hope, Still Into You

A step up from their debut. To be honest I’m not the biggest fan of pop punk but there were still a lot of bangers on here like Misery Business, For a Pessimist, and Fences.