Mess

Critic Score
Based on 32 reviews
2014 Ratings: #346 / 1066
User Score
Based on 346 ratings
2014 Ratings: #308
March 25, 2014 / Release Date
LP / Format
Mute / Label
Angus AndrewProducer
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
musicOMH

This is undoubtedly Liars’ most engaging work

90
No Ripcord

Now seven albums deep into their career, Liars remain a lasting and distinguished presence, one that continues to question the confinement of genre and fashions their identity around a refusal to do so.

85
The Line of Best Fit

Mess is characteristically confident and brash, but humane and enduring. In short, it’s up there with the rest of their unerringly brilliant back-catalogue.

85
Under the Radar

The kind of envelope-pushing on Mess is nothing if not mature, simultaneously punk as fuck and utterly refined.

83
Pretty Much Amazing

As the trio continue to remould and refine their craft, Mess, an album fuelled by impulse, demonstrates their ideological core hasn’t moved an inch.

80
Drowned in Sound

The homogeneity of sound is fascinating and oppressive and inscrutable, a brooding cosmic puzzle that Liars keep rearranging to new effects and opaque ends.

80
The Needle Drop
Liars continue their foray into electronic music with a series of incredibly bold, heavy tech house fusions.
80
Slant Magazine

Mess may be Liars’ darkest album, which is saying a lot for a band so well versed in cultic, gloomy theatrics.

80
Exclaim!

As with their previous six albums, Liars find a way to both innovate and deliver a brand-loyal effort with (dis)ease.

80
The Skinny

By and large, it’s a beast of a record and free from overtly po-faced earnestness

80
DIY

With overwhelming confidence the Brooklyn-based trio present 11 songs of unerring quality and an almost uncountable numbers of flicks and tricks. 

80
SPIN

It pretty much encapsulates the band's evolution -- from scrappy startups in Brooklyn's turn-of-the-century dance-punk scene to witchcraft storytellers bashing nebulous sounds together to ambient-electro perfectionists. 

80
NME

If there’s a record that sums up the spirit of Liars – that dedication to unsettling, disorientating anarchy – ‘Mess’ may just be it.

80
AllMusic

Even if it's not quite as striking an achievement as WIXIW, it's a lot of fun and shows, once again, that Liars are unquestionably themselves no matter how much they push their boundaries.

75
The 405

Uniquely with Mess, they've instead dealt with the most colossal environment, making a grander statement about the aphotic bleakness of society in the process.

75
A.V. Club

Mess is a dense record for big rooms, demanding to be heard with potent subwoofers.

70
FACT Magazine

Not only is Mess Liars’ first ‘dance album’, it’s also their most pop - the Liars’ sound distilled to a motorcade of hook-after-hook insta-gratification events.

70
PopMatters

As Liars continue their hiatus from the trappings of rock with Mess, they’ve created what is without a doubt their least innovative and least gloriously messy album.

69
Pitchfork

As enjoyable as it can be, Mess is a centrist record from a band without a lot of centrist strengths and appreciating it can feel like a symbolic gesture

60
Paste

Most of the album scans as half-baked and tossed off, a swift break with the quality of the band’s prior output.

50
Tiny Mix Tapes

On the one hand, they sound like they’ve kept apace with musical trends and integrated them accordingly; on the other, it sounds like they’ve got some cool new toys but not a lot of new ideas.

50
Consequence of Sound

I find it hard to listen to Mess and not miss the rampant motion of Sisterworld, the clever melodies of WIXIW, or the way Drums Not Dead draws hot air tight around itself for what can feel like hours. Mess gets caught in an odd trap in that it’s neither patient nor nimble.

LZGray
80

A freaky, unsettling experimental dance project with ugly guitar tones and synths, perpetually looping into paranoia. A challenging atmosphere that's still really freaking groovy.

dearsongs
NR

One of my favorites from one of the most consistent bands around. More industrial than some of their other work. Goth dance party time.

Camelcap
79

Need to listen

More popular reviews
johan_ht
95

Sometimes I just dive into a random niche album from a music genre that I m not used to and I get blown away, 'Mess' is a perfect example of that

Toamea
87

Mano pra que tlgd? que BAGUNÇA com esses fio ai pô, mô trabalheira vai dar pra arrumar isso aí, paia de mais, também pô, os caba são maior MENTIROSOS :/

Pra quem curte o primeiro álbum do "Crystal Castles" é um projeto bem legal, é uma pegada meio electro com experimentalismo, bem interessante o projeto

Dreamyreviews
92

Oh yeah I get this album for sure. Mess by Liars is a great Electro-Industrial album with blends of Experimental Rock and New Rave. Idk how I didn’t get to this album sooner because this was right up my alley, it’s got so much personality and great production with a weird atmosphere to accompany it. I mean I really think the cover art matches how this album is, it’s odd but charming. I’m surprised this would even come from a band that had already released so much stuff ... read more

More recent reviews
Purchasing Mess from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist