Electric Circus

Critic Score
Based on 14 reviews
2002 Ratings: #69 / 322
User Score
Based on 317 ratings
2002 Ratings: #576
December 10, 2002 / Release Date
LP / Format
MCA / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
The Guardian

Electric Circus feels like an epochal blueprint for what hip-hop can be: it is visceral, genuinely experimental and fascinatingly odd while remaining, essentially, a pop record.

100
Entertainment Weekly
Although he can be self-righteous, scattered, and grim, a team of truly youthful-minded producers is there to color the gray.
80
AllMusic

Electric Circus does suffer from that which ails many contemporary hip-hop albums -- too many guests and a generally lengthy program drag this one down a tad. Nonetheless, Electric Circus is a brave and ruthless statement wrapped in sincerity.

80
NME
Common has just gone way, way off the hip-hop map.
80
Slant Magazine
Common channels the ghosts of Jimi Hendrix and Jim Morrison to achieve a post-gangsta rap hybrid unlike anything else out today.
80
Alternative Press
Even the psychedelic overreach shows a most uncommon artist at work.
80
Uncut

To be filed alongside the Root's recent Phrenology.

80
NOW Magazine
It's unlike anything else out there, and when it works, it's astonishing. Unlike, say, the Roots, though, Common often sounds too smart and eclectic for his own good, like he's just experimenting for the sake of it.
80
Prefix
If you like conscious rap mixed with a fresh, original sound, you should dig this.
80
Q Magazine

It works ... stretching rap into weird new shapes.

70
RapReviews.com

He needs to go the fuck back to Chicago and get with his old crew again; cause this shit ain’t working.

65
Pitchfork

This time out, Com comes off as alternately uncomfortable and downright lazy, half-speaking-- or worse, singing-- new-age revelations to the masses.

60
SPIN
The storytelling here isn't as sharp as on Common's previous albums.
60
Rolling Stone
Somehow, Common makes it all fly, breaking hip-hop rules with a freewheeling fearlessness worthy of his guitar-god muse.
Rollo_P
66

We really need a chapter in hip hop that goes over all the potential other outcomes that would've been present had Erykah Badu not pussy whipped all the top tier MC's that she did. How the hell do you go from Like Water For Chocolate to this *without* losing Dilla or Questlove?

AllAboutMusic
87

Common's previous project, Like Water For Chocolate, is considered by many people (including myself) to be one of hip hop's all time greatest albums. It got lots of critical acclaim, and is still loved by so many nearly 23 years since it's released. Common could’ve easily replicated this sound and made LWFC 2, but decided to take a risk and make his most unique, experimental project to date. The outcome: one of the most forward thinking rap albums of the 2000s. Even just the album cover ... read more

WM0002
80

I don't get the hate this shit is funky as hell

More popular reviews
81

-------------------------------------------------------------------

70

This is Common's Phrenology. His first 4 albums had a clear progression in sound and content, and this album really threw that off. There are a lot of good moments, and I acknowledge the talent and creativity behind this, but unfortunately this album falls too far from my taste in music to give it anything higher than this.

DaMusicManKing
88

Great work, it's common at the end of the day, but he didn't go all the way with it though.

More recent reviews
Purchasing Electric Circus from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

June Playlist