Preacher's Daughter

Critic Score
Based on 17 reviews
2022 Ratings: #39 / 815
Year-End Rank: #19
User Score
2022 Ratings: #10All Time: #398
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
DIY
Change, escape and identity are not easy things to navigate, and ‘Preacher’s Daughter’ is the dark, unsettling, sprawling beauty that comes out of it.
100
Sputnikmusic

Preacher’s Daughter is a record that breathes authenticity while reframing and reshaping its creator’s experiences, seemingly in hopes of finding some sense or purpose.

90
Still Listening

Preacher’s Daughter is without a doubt a top contender for album of the year. It’s a true masterpiece, a melting pot of macabre storytelling and ambient music. No one is doing it quite like Ethel Cain.

90
Paste
The artist’s debut LP interweaves powerful genre influences and haunting narratives, beginning to chart the Ethel Cain lore.
90
The Line of Best Fit

There's a substance and cohesion across Preacher's Daughter that's lacking on most debuts – and yet there's clearly so much more to come from this incredible artist and the rich world she's created.

90
Clash

A heart-wrenching collection of songs that urges the listener to give themselves over to this album as much as Ethel Cain gives herself over to you.

90
The Young Folks

Ethereal and devastating, Preacher’s Daughter is a startling demonstration of talent by Ethel Cain. The album cultivates and brandishes a voice worth stopping and listening to and, ultimately, fully submerging to.

90
Uncut
No true-crime podcast ever sounded this ravishing and atmospheric.
90
Crack Magazine
This is an album that pairs cock-rock riffs and 80s snares with thundering sludge and drone instrumentals.
90
Gigwise

Because she has, and the magic of Ethel Cain is her ability to translate that lived experience into soundscapes. Preacher's Daughter is an American epic.

88
Northern Transmissions

Combining the storytelling of Taylor Swift’s folklore and the musical theater readiness of Spellling’s The Turning Wheel, Preacher’s Daughter comes across more like an event than any singular album.

80
AllMusic

A concept album following three generations of women as they navigate the turbulent waters of family trauma, violence, and misogyny, Preacher's Daughter is awash in Southern gothic imagery, dreamy Americana, and deep spiritual discord.

80
Albumism
As a whole, the album is a sweeping Southern Gothic, with all of the odd-but-relatable characters and beautiful sadness of a Carson McCullers or Flannery O’Connor novel, as well as all of the twisted, cruel tragedy.
80
Beats Per Minute
With more questions raised than answered, Cain’s unusually ambitious and fully-realised debut somehow leaves listeners craving more in spite of its wonderful, exhausting, 75 minute runtime.
64
Pitchfork

On her debut album, the 24-year-old Tallahassee native briefly makes good on her instinct for mass-appeal pop anthems, but most of the 76-minute album dwells on roiling gloom and smoldering Americana.

60
The Needle Drop

The music on Preacher’s Daughter could offer its harrowing narrative more support.

60
The Guardian
The introspective singer explores identity and religion amid a backdrop of seedy Americana on this rich, haunting debut.
Irissssssssssss
100

Edit: fuck it, there’s no more denying it, this is my favorite album of all time. Almost no album has ever had the same emotional personal impact on me as this one has

Am I really doing another really longer, even longer than the last version review of this album? Yes, yes I am. I currently am like just addicted to all her music (like I cannot stop fucking listening to it nonstop), her aesthetic, this entire world she’s created with her music, it’s just all so amazing and I ... read more

BaddieBaphomet
90

Huh. So I guess “Ants From Up There” might not have Album of the Year in the bag as easily as I thought.

Ethel Cain is the kind of name only a dying grandmother would have, but it’s also the pseudonym of art pop and southern gothic singer, songwriter, and producer Hayden Silas Anhedönia. Ethel Cain is also a character meant to reflect Anhedönia but if she were to not learn from the bad experiences life has thrown her way. Hayden has been self producing her own music ... read more

TheNevermeant
90

Ethereal, ambitious, and heart-wrenching beyond compare, “Preacher’s Daughter” stands as one of the most impressive debuts of the past 20 years.

Since Hayden has quickly become something of a goddess I aspire to lick the footsteps of - and since “Willoughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love You” looms before us like an emotional wrecking-ball - I thought it was high time to discuss one of the most fascinating recent projects to have graced this mortal globe. ... read more

More popular reviews
90

The tone is set in the first line, and the album follows through on it. A masterpieces that drones through my body and leaves me full and empty all at the same time.

tiredofthisshit
72

before ptolemaea:

ahhh ahhh i fucking hate the drums so much ahhh ahhh

during ptolemaea:

omg this is like one of the best songs ever wow

after ptolemaea:

these are also like the best songs ever yippeeeeee (the drums are still here a little bit but not enough to be a problem i still hate them though)

DeadDiscoDancer
NR

Shout out to my friend who was there to watch my live reaction to listened to this album for the first time. I really, really do adore albums that are strongly atmospheric- and a concept album too? I'm all for it. The storyline is just tragic and the callbacks gave me physical reactions. Crazy debut

First listened 29th May 2026

More recent reviews
Purchasing Preacher's Daughter from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?

April Playlist