Kill The Moonlight

Critic Score
Based on 8 reviews
2002 Ratings: #81 / 322
User Score
Based on 493 ratings
2002 Ratings: #264
August 20, 2002 / Release Date
LP / Format
Merge, 12XU / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
Entertainment Weekly
Could be the Strokes in 10 years–if they work hard.
89
Pitchfork

This record is an adventure in starkness, beyond Girls Can Tell even while evoking some of that album's finest moments.

80
AllMusic

Though the album's brittle immediacy is far from a disappointment, and the quick turnaround between Kill the Moonlight and their previous one is a treat for Spoon fans, one can't help but notice that this album just isn't as revelatory as Girls Can Tell.

80
Uncut

They make you happy, and remind you why you're sad: the perfect high.

70
Tiny Mix Tapes

The elements used are essential to the entire makeup of the song, whereas the rest of the songs try to flourish themselves with asinine bells & whistles, waddling back and forth between intricacy and simplicity, but ultimately come off sub par at best.

70
NME
70
SPIN
The result is indie-rock as passive-aggressive blues implosion.
60
Rolling Stone

With Kill the moonlight, Spoon complete their transformation from ragtag rockers into beat-driven post-punks.

N_C_R
86

Okay, fine. You could say I've been obsessed with Spoon recently, but it is for good reason. Okay!!!!????

I promise this band isn't consuming me whole, they're just.... so.... consistently.... good

One of Spoon's signature attributes is their studio trickery, and no other album of theirs demonstrates this more than Kill The Moonlight

This album came out in 2002, and the use of space and binaural audio (when you hear different instruments playing in each earpiece) still ... read more

Calvino
73

Spoon is one of those band's I will keep saying "Oh I'll get to them later" over and over again but still have no plan of when I actually will get to them. With that being said Kill The Moonlight has been an album that has been recommended to me for some time and since I don't want to fully commit to listening to their discography just yet, I am deciding to just skip some of their work so I can knock this thing out for now. I wasn't expecting to see such clear 60s and 70s rock ... read more

Doofy
73

Fourth album 'Kill the Moonlight' picks up where its predecessor left off but starts going for an even more deconstructed sound with the band embracing the joys of economy in their arrangements. You get the feeling that, for the next few albums at least, Spoon were really trying to strip their music down to the essence, making sure not to overstuff their songs with anything superfluous.

It's an approach that works and makes the band feel a little more unique than before, their songs are ... read more

More popular reviews
Anno
78

Step down from Girls Can Tell, but still pretty good.

Playlist-Worthy Tracks: The Way We Get Back, Jonathan Fisk, Paper Tiger, Don't Let It Get You Down,

90

You gotta feel it and paper tiger are my two skips

RowanSmith
80

Best utensil 🥄

More recent reviews
Purchasing Kill The Moonlight from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Year End Lists

#6/Pitchfork
#38/SPIN

More Lists
Comments (3)
Sign in to comment
1y
1y
1y

April Playlist