Best of 2026

underscores - U
underscores
U
80
May 13

Recently Rated

The The - Infected
The The
Infected
1986 • LP
70
4h ago
Botch
American Nervoso
1998 • LP
70
May 25
Paul Simon - Graceland
Paul Simon
Graceland
1986 • LP
80
May 25
Arthur Russell - Iowa Dream
Arthur Russell
Iowa Dream
2019 • LP
70
May 24
Paul Simon - Paul Simon
Paul Simon
Paul Simon
1972 • LP
70
May 22
Neil Young & Crazy Horse - Rust Never Sleeps
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
Rust Never Sleeps
1979 • LP
70
May 19
Polaris - Home
Polaris
Home
2002 • LP
80
May 18

Pinned Review

Modest Mouse - The Lonesome Crowded West
100

Modest Mouse - 4/13

A perfectly imperfect album.

Nothing about the long and winding indie-rock opus that is 1997’s “The Lonesome Crowded West” falls flat. Throughout its 73 minute runtime, there is not a single dull moment; not a single moment I’m not completely absorbed by the music. What Modest Mouse established stylistically with their first releases, they utterly perfected here.

When I say perfected, I mean that everything just clicks. Even with its flaws, ... read more

Recent Reviews

Modest Mouse - Good News For People Who Love Bad News
80

I think I'm done with reviewing for a bit.

Lately, I barely ever find a time where I want to sit down and write. Whereas this feeling in the past used to be accompanied by a general music burnout for me, now it's different; I've absolutely loved listening to music the last couple months. I just don't feel inspired to write anymore. Anytime I do, it feels like a chore and that really shouldn't be the case for something like this. I shouldn't spend my free time ... read more

Modest Mouse - Everywhere And His Nasty Parlour Tricks
60

Modest Mouse - 8/13

"Everywhere And His Nasty Parlour Tricks" serves as a collection of outtakes from the recording sessions for "The Moon & Antarctica". So, it makes sense that it carries on the same vibe the band brought to that album, even featuring many nods to it, such as some reused lyrics, "The Air" essentially being a sort of remix of "Lives," and "I Came As a Rat" seeing the EP out.

But sadly, this project doesn't do nearly ... read more

Modest Mouse - Sad Sappy Sucker
60

Modest Mouse - 7/13

Originally set to be Modest Mouse’s 1994 debut album, “Sad Sappy Sucker” was unfortunately shelved until — in the wake of “The Moon and Antarctica’s” great commercial success — Isaac Brock decided he wanted to revisit and rerecord these tunes. Does it hold up in terms of quality when compared to the rest of the band’s work?

Well, kinda. Hints of the greatness they would come to achieve are certainly felt here and there, ... read more

Modest Mouse - The Moon & Antarctica
90

Modest Mouse - 6/13

"The universe is shaped exactly like the Earth / If you go straight long enough you'll end up where you were."

Released during the summer of 2000, Modest Mouse's major label debut "The Moon & Antarctica" sees their sound evolving in a multitude of ways. The production is far cleaner than before and every song is structured properly with a strong sense of order and direction. But to accompany this more polished feel come some of the ... read more

Modest Mouse - Building Nothing Out of Something
80

Modest Mouse - 5/13

Consisting of various singles released between 1996 and 1998 and also the first three (amazing) songs off of the “Interstate 8” EP, “Building Nothing Out of Something” stands as a pretty great sampler for Modest Mouse’s early work.

Songs like “Never Ending Math Equation” and “Grey Ice Water” are perfectly indicative of the group’s sound, the former an energetic groover with shifting dynamics, and the latter a ... read more


April Playlist