Ghost Stories

Critic Score
Based on 39 reviews
2014 Ratings: #975 / 1066
User Score
2014 Ratings: #771
May 19, 2014 / Release Date
LP / Format
Parlophone / Label
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

90
Billboard

“Ghost Stories” is the sound of Coldplay rejecting its inner Coldplay-ness, at least for one album. Martin and the rest of the band will no doubt spring back to life on future releases, but for once, reveling in the darkness sounds like a great idea.

80
Evening Standard

With lush, ambient textures, Ghost Stories is produced to perfection. Ultimately, though, it’s Martin’s haunting choruses that make it Coldplay’s most affecting album since their debut.

80
The Irish Times
Paradoxically, without Brian Eno on board, this is Coldplay's most Eno-sounding album: a muted, sad ambience hangs like a melancholic miasma over eight of the nine tracks.
80
AllMusic

Coldplay may not be forceful, but within their incessant politeness they do have a distinctive personality, one that shines through whatever tricks individual producers bring to the table.

80
FasterLouder
Ghost Stories is a proper journey, and certainly Coldplay’s most emotive and gripping work yet.
75
Paste

It’s them getting back to their roots after taking the majority of the world by storm. For the most part, gone is the orchestral, light experimentalism of Viva la Vida and the synthed-out bombast of Mylo Xyloto.

75
Entertainment Weekly

It’s a drowsy experience, and often a true bummer; for all his skilled self-deprecation, Martin sounds genuinely heartbroken. But Ghost Stories can’t help but feel like a prelude to something bigger and deeper.

75
The Line of Best Fit

As much as Martin may emphasise it being a learning curve or “joyful realisation” about the ups and downs of love, it’s inescapably, undeniably a break-up album. Rousing, downtempo pop to soothe a troubled soul. ​

70
NME

This isn't quite early Coldplay rebooted. It shares a simple sparseness with 'Parachutes', but the approach is radically different.

70
SPIN

This doesn't mean Ghost Stories is a bleak album. In fact, its deep sea of synth-encrusted pop glistens under a halo of angelic ambient touches and Martin's ever-rosy perspective

70
No Ripcord

On Ghost Stories, despite a near derailment, they "fly on," moving in fresh directions while keep the catharsis that gave them their audience in the first place.

70
Rolling Stone
For the first time in ages, Martin isn’t trying to “Fix You.” Now he needs to repair himself.
67
A.V. Club

Martin does a touching though frequently ham-handed job of working through his feelings, at least on eight of these nine tracks.

60
The Arts Desk

Rock stars have a way of seeming impregnable but Martin comes across bereft.

60
Wondering Sound

Subdued but rarely sullen, heartbroken yet resilient, Ghost Stories is musical comfort food. And no matter the sonic landscape, that’s what Coldplay do best.

60
The Guardian

Ghost Stories is an album that, metaphorically speaking, just mopes about the place in its dressing gown, too sorry for itself to do or say much.

60
The Independent

Mostly ... this is music that keeps its head down. Martin accepts his loss too meekly to approach the anguish of a great break-up album. A step away from grand platitudes is still one in the right direction.

60
The Telegraph

Although the results are more hazy blue than golden, Coldplay’s sixth album sounds like the work of a man meditating on things.

60
Slant Magazine

Ghost Stories isn’t the return to basics the band hinted at during interviews, nor does it need to be.

60
Hot Press
If ghost stories are intended to be an enjoyable diversion before bed time, they’ve succeeded. If you’re looking for an adrenaline rush or big reveal, however, this is probably not the place to find it.
60
Drowned in Sound

You can feel the thought and polish that has gone into everything, and though Ghost Stories is almost unprecedentedly pared down and shorn of ego for a sixth album by an act of this stature, the music never has the ragged quality to put it in sync with Martin's voice. 

60
Exclaim!

It has brief sparks of a fresh creativity and has plenty of potential, but doesn't take steps bold enough to totally reinvent itself, making for a record littered with moments that let it sink into the forgettable parts of the band's catalogue.

60
musicOMH

But you do get a short and sweet nine-track exorcism of demons and one crushed dude who knows how to pen some beautiful, infectious ballads.

60
American Songwriter

While there are moments in which Coldplay take some interesting steps forward on Ghost Stories, there are a few moments when the band rests a little too heavily on easy listening or pop music clichés. 

60
DIY

‘Ghost Stories’ is the sound of Coldplay finally coming to terms with who they are - a universally loved, often loathed, slightly cheesy outfit. 

58
Consequence of Sound

Even though it’s not Coldplay’s strongest, Ghost Stories should be applauded for scaling back the gaudy excesses of their previous albums. 

56
Sputnikmusic

Overall, Coldplay’s decision to drop back a couple of gears does not serve them well, especially given the fact that the quality of Martin’s lyrics rarely rise above the serviceable. 

50
Pretty Much Amazing

For an album that aims to explore the most emotional time in Martin’s life, Ghost Stories stands as Coldplay’s most distancing effort to date.

50
The Sydney Morning Herald

It’s a better album than 2011’s huge, hollow Mylo Xyloto, but it’s clear that Martin prefers plucky survival to soulful self-examination.

50
Spill Magazine
Don’t listen to me, I’m down in the dumps from listening to this album 18 times. Maybe I’m cynical because I haven’t broken up with someone in years and yearn to write a sad song about them.
44
Pitchfork

Ghost Stories is unmistakably Coldplay's "breakup album," a subdued work that finds Martin and his band crisply moping through mid-tempo soundscapes and fuzzy electronic touches that have the visceral impact of a down comforter tumbling down a flight of stairs.

40
The Needle Drop

Coldplay's Ghost Stories is their dreamiest, most serene effort thus far.

40
The Observer
As it is, these ghost stories pack few chills.
40
NOW Magazine
We all love to revel in a real tearjerker, but these whiney odes are heartbreak songs minus the heart.
40
Clash
From moments that recall Bon Iver to others which summon the aesthetic of previous producer Brian Eno but stop short of his spirit, Martin’s morose men have rarely been so invisible on their own material.
40
Time Out London

Weighing in at a scant 40 minutes, the tone of ‘Ghost Stories’ is electronic and plodding, not guitary and surging. Forget the idea of Coldplay writing for stadiums – this is the sound of a band restraining themselves and desperately holding it in.

30
Spectrum Culture

Coldplay were at their best when they were still writing songs for themselves, not meeting expectations. And while Ghost Stories revolves around the inward, personal aesthetic of Martin’s relationship status, the final product feels crafted out of obligation, not passion.

30
PopMatters

Despite all the emotional gravitas and metaphysical significance Coldplay wishes to impart with this album, the tunes are too flat to hit home at their best and perilously teetering over the edge of plagiarism at their worst.

20
God Is in the TV
Even by Coldplay’s peerless standards then, this is a dull, lifeless record, its brevity (9 tracks) its only positive quality.
ST4T1C
100

I can see why most people would hate this album, as "Ghost Stories" is a very quite, ambient, and lowkey album. It is because of this, I legitimately loved this album, and I honestly do consider it to be as good as some of Coldplays other projects. There are so many just magical moments on here like "Oceans" and "Midnight". Even some of the lesser tracks like "Another's Arms" is still amazing, and honestly, "A Sky Full Of Stars", while a little ... read more

KaitoNkmra
91

I seem to be in the minority here that absolutely loves this album. This honestly felt like a nostalgic step back to some of Coldplay's older works but with an ambient and at times electronic twist. I can agree that it's slow overall but people are making this to be a bad thing, which I don't think it is since it fits the tone of the record perfectly.

There's a healthy mix of beautiful acoustic tracks like Oceans and O, mix of this and electronic pop like in Magic and Ink, and while I think A ... read more

elitimesfour
69

I recind my previous statement this is pretty nice, a sky full of stars is such a dumb closer tho (good song isolated from that however)

😴😴🥱😮😐

More popular reviews
Maksim_38
100

So calm. So slow. So relaxing. So beautiful. So perfect.

FaceBrookeDtCom
91

A shorter than usual album from the Coldplay lads, but they have very much subscribed to the “Quality over Quantity” mantra. Songs like Magic and O are soft and slow, giving you time to fully digest everything going on, and the overall slowness of the album makes the sudden switch up into A Sky Full of Stars hit with full force. Honestly, I think this has beaten out Viva La Vida for the best Coldplay album

ezrachickengoob
75

decent album but why is "a sky full of stars" there?? AND WHY IS IT THE SECOND TO LAST SONG

More recent reviews
Purchasing Ghost Stories from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1Always In My Head
3:36
79
2Magic
4:45
81
3Ink
3:48
75
4True Love
4:05
76
5Midnight
4:54
83
6Another's Arms
3:54
72
7Oceans
5:21
73
8A Sky Full of Stars
4:28
77
9O
7:46
Contains hidden track "Fly On"
84
Total Length: 42 minutes
Sign in to comment
1w
3w
1mo
2mo
3mo

June Playlist