CRAWLER

Critic Score
Based on 29 reviews
2021 Ratings: #319 / 756
Year-End Rank: #31
User Score
2021 Ratings: #292
November 12, 2021 / Release Date
LP / Format
Partisan / Label
IDLESWriter
Full Credits
Sign In to rate and review

Critic Reviews

100
The Observer

Glass-gargling frontman Joe Talbot disinters his lifelong struggle with substance abuse over 14 songs, circling around a traumatic, drug-fuelled car crash. The band use everything they’ve got.

90
musicOMH

The dark, introspective nature of Idles’ latest release may well disappoint those who love the band for their rabble-rousing, tongue-in-cheek headbangers. But for those who’ve been waiting some time for the beloved Bristolians to take a left turn with their sound, Crawler is an absolute thrill.

88
Paste

CRAWLER is a project about flaws, healing and reclamation. It’s a remarkable, haunted and resonate touchstone for rock and roll, a record unafraid of its own emotions and openness—full of stories worth returning to and untangling a hundred times over.

80
Mojo

Idles are finding new directions home: the hallmark of a great band.

80
Rolling Stone UK

The latest record from IDLES sees them taking a brave first step outside their comfort zone.

80
Evening Standard

There are occasional subtleties, as with the scratchy electronic layers on Progress, and something approaching conventional singing on the almost pretty The Beachland Ballroom. But the sound overall is pure battering ram.

80
Classic Rock

The crepuscular and electro-flecked Crawler works almost as a scream-therapy confessional, Talbot laying bare his history of addiction and degradation as a token of solidarity to those broken by the pandemic.

80
Record Collector
Over 14 bruising tracks, there’s no sign of frontman Joe Talbot’s unambiguously right- on polemic, not much humour and little in the way of festival-ready shoutalongs. It also might be the band’s most satisfying collection of songs to date.
80
Gigwise

Post-punk has always been a genre that only vaguely fitted IDLES, used only because it was a convenient way to compare them to their contemporaries. In some ways, CRAWLER is the closest that the Bristol five-piece have come to the now-overused label, but the album is, at its core, unpredictable.

80
Kerrang!

This might be a more reflective, experimental IDLES, but they remain a band filled equally with anger, humour and vitriol. And, whichever direction they take, it still sounds fantastic.

80
Northern Transmissions

Long may IDLES challenge their own sonic personality, along with social norms and the notion of what it is to be strong but also what it is to be vulnerable. All is love.

80
The Independent

The band’s signature punk rock sound underpins the album, but it’s on the stylistically divergent tracks that Idles flex a new skill. Crawler is ambitious in its scope, and it almost always pays off.

80
Clash
IDLES' fourth record in just as many years is their most ambitious, most introspective, and most powerful to date.
80
AllMusic
It has the potential to open the door to the Idles multiverse, where multiple versions of the band co-exist. Whilst it doesn't always stick the landing, the new spaces it does explore are well worth the journey.
80
NME

The Bristol band's fourth album is a course correction, one that dials down the aggression in favour of reflection.

80
Under the Radar

CRAWLER is the sound of a band intently looking forwards, even if that means revisiting their demons from the past.

80
DIY
Things get truly exciting when IDLES combine the atmospheric with the experimental.
80
The Line of Best Fit

Once again, the band finds healing and beauty in their own chaotic vortex, and once again they invite everyone listening to do the same, joining them on their most exploratory and cathartic ride yet.

80
Sputnikmusic

Crawler sees IDLES go beyond their signature sound.

79
Far Out Magazine
You can’t help but sense that the band knew they were on to a winner, and fair play, as they’ve earned it.
72
Beats Per Minute

All in all, Crawler is a return to form for IDLES, albeit with a handful of sub-par offerings. There’s still more than enough here for them to be rabble-rousing festival headliners, but also some tracks that offer up new ideas that they could carry forward.

72
Spectrum Culture

It’s not the most welcoming IDLES record, nor does it represent the band at their artistic peak. Depending on what happens next, though, it might be the most important record in the band’s career, for regardless of its overall quality, Crawler does open up a realm of different artistic possibilities for a band that some had previously thought to be one-note.

70
Loud and Quiet

If Crawler has a message, it’s that while it’s important to recognise the sins of the past, it does no good to dwell on them.

70
Pitchfork
Exploring personal subject matter and wider musical terrain, the Bristol band’s fourth album plays like the dark origin story for how Idles became the preeminent life coaches of modern post-punk.
70
Uncut

The follow-up to Ultra Mono is a rich panorama of addiction.

60
The Needle Drop

Crawler lacks the impact of the band's past few LPs.

60
The Arts Desk

An album whose jagged thoughtfulness creates a sonic mood that seems to reflect a society in sinister freefall. It’s a mostly vital if sometimes bleak ride.

40
Exclaim!

CRAWLER is the sound of Idles running on empty.

40
RIOT

CRAWLER is an album born out of a near car crash – an event that inspired frontman Joe Talbot to deeply reflect on life, death and his own experience as a recovering addict.

DonCorleone
97

ouch

SnowyFighter
80

Crawl straight to the top of the charts my boys

This is great. This is awesome. With this album, it feels like Idles are just evolving on their sound, and are trying new things. I feel like at this point in their career, it’s a great move. I liked Ultra Mono, but with that album it felt like they were just staying in their lane. With songs like MTT 420 RR, and The Beachland Ballroom on this album, it’s the opposite. Even if every song isn’t a hit, there is a really solid ... read more

MasterCrackfox
92

Thus far in the career of IDLES the group have stayed married to their particular style of aggression, riddled in socio-political vitriol, humor, and violence. For some, their previous effort last year could have been seen as a safe one, remaining close to the material of their smash debut and critically beloved sophomore effort, but with a little less punch and fewer memorable moments. As much as they had become fresh staples in the punk scene, they ran the risk of becoming stale if they ... read more

More popular reviews
Y2Jess
88

There is none of the usual Joe Talbot humor here, this is a record of painstaking introspection. The band delivers some of their most subtly impressive studio performances yet, a very welcome progression from the near auto-pilot nature of Ultra Mono.

gdawgstudios
77

DAMAGE DAMAGE DAMAGE

Lemom
80

stilistische experimentellere weiterentwicklung. Hittet nicht immer, wenn es jedoch funktioniert ist es wahnsinnig stark

More recent reviews
Purchasing CRAWLER from Amazon helps support Album of the Year. Or consider a donation?
Become a Subscriber
Subscriber badge, no ads + more benefits.
Advertisement

Track List

1MTT 420 RR
5:30
86
2The Wheel
3:25
83
3When the Lights Come On
3:11
80
4Car Crash
3:53
87
5The New Sensation
4:13
77
6Stockholm Syndrome
3:02
79
7The Beachland Ballroom
4:00
93
8Crawl!
4:20
85
9Meds
3:56
79
10Kelechi
0:29
66
11Progress
3:46
81
12Wizz
0:30
71
13King Snake
2:54
75
14The End
3:18
81
Total Length: 46 minutes
Sign in to comment
6mo
7mo
10mo
1y
1y

June Playlist